The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement
Good Food hat15.5/20Critics' Pick

Mister Grotto

Mister Grotto is set among a new strip of venues on Australia Street.
1 / 10Mister Grotto is set among a new strip of venues on Australia Street.Jennifer Soo
Yellowfin tuna with green sauce, daikon and finger lime.
2 / 10Yellowfin tuna with green sauce, daikon and finger lime. Jennifer Soo
Pipis with dry vermouth, samphire and lavender honey cornbread.
3 / 10Pipis with dry vermouth, samphire and lavender honey cornbread. Jennifer Soo
Barbecued nannygai, sweetcorn and manchego.
4 / 10Barbecued nannygai, sweetcorn and manchego.Jennifer Soo
Coconut and pineapple baba.
5 / 10Coconut and pineapple baba.Jennifer Soo
After Eight dessert with white chocolate and salted caramel or dark chocolate with peppermint cream.
6 / 10After Eight dessert with white chocolate and salted caramel or dark chocolate with peppermint cream.Jennifer Soo
Chartreuse caipirinha.
7 / 10Chartreuse caipirinha.Jennifer Soo
Knick-knacks on the wall.
8 / 10Knick-knacks on the wall. Jennifer Soo
Timber-panelled walls line the dining room.
9 / 10Timber-panelled walls line the dining room. Jennifer Soo
Fresh seafood is displayed on ice.
10 / 10Fresh seafood is displayed on ice. Jennifer Soo
Chef of the Year 2026Presented by Oceania Cruises
Good Food hat15.5/20Critics' Pick

Mister Grotto

Seafood$$

New Orleans oyster shack meets Sydney wine bar.

There’s a bit going on here. Fishing rods. Hand-reels. Antique lures. Vintage navy plaques adorned with a penguin, platypus and waterhen. Not that we expected anything less from the Continental Deli team and their recent Newtown expansion which also includes meat-forward Osteria Mucca next door.

Mans Engberg leads the kitchen and sends out clever flavour-packed dishes such as cuttlefish tangled with young coconut, grilled calamari teamed with ink sauce and chestnut mushrooms (it works), and pipis served in a froth of vermouth and samphire with steaming, pull-apart cornbread.

Chef Lauren Eldridge is on dessert duties across the four Australia Street sites, and at Mister Grotto she remixes the After Eight mint into a beautiful lobster-shaped mould starring white chocolate, salted caramel and a Fisherman’s Friend-based tincture, while a swirling tower of buttermilk soft serve is dolled up with fig compote and gold-standard honeycomb.

Must order: Shallow-fried shishito peppers stuffed with sausage made from the bloodline of tuna. Few snacks will pair better with cold sake.

Advertisement

Good Food reviews are booked anonymously and paid independently. A restaurant can’t pay for a review or inclusion in the Good Food Guide.

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up

Continue this series

Inner West and Western Sydney
Up next
Sujouk sausage.
  • Review

Mixed Business Enmore

Neighbourhood bar telling its own Australian story.

Hot Salami pizza with jalapenos.
  • Review

MMC Slice Shoppe

Fun, nostalgia-sparking US-style pizzeria.

Previously
Kingfish crudo with calamansi dressing at MISC in Parramatta.
  • Review

Misc.

Elevated brunch, lunch and dinner in Western Sydney’s prettiest park.

See all stories

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement