The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement
Good Food hat15/20Critics' Pick

Osteria Mucca

Gnudi with brown butter and sage.
1 / 6Gnudi with brown butter and sage. Wolter Peeters
Cassata.
2 / 6Cassata. Wolter Peeters
The dining room.
3 / 6The dining room. Wolter Peeters
Bread and ricotta.
4 / 6Bread and ricotta. Wolter Peeters
Cotechino.
5 / 6Cotechino. Wolter Peeters
The word “mucca” means cow in Italian.
6 / 6The word “mucca” means cow in Italian. Wolter Peeters
Chef of the Year 2026Presented by Oceania Cruises
Good Food hat15/20Critics' Pick

Osteria Mucca

Italian$$$

The third new Newtown venture from the Continental Deli crew.

What is luxury, anyway? Lobster, caviar, high marble-score wagyu? Osteria Mucca, one of three new openings – along with Mister Grotto and (soon to rebrand) Flora – joining Continental Deli in a strip on Australia Street, says no thanks. Reflecting the site’s history as a butcher, chef Janina Allende homes in on alternative cuts, coaxing them to deliciousness through time and attentive cooking.

Coppa di testa, say, with strips of pig’s ear throughout. Or cotechino, the gutsy pork sausage checked with salsa verde and mustard fruits. Candles flicker, plates are rimmed in gold, tables dressed with tablecloths hum with activity. This, too, is luxury, although it’s not all deep cuts.

House ricotta is crowdpleasing comfort and a plate of lamb turns out to be the city’s finest mixed grill, while pastry chef Lauren Eldridge’s Sicilian cassata is fast becoming the stuff of legend. And hey, there’s always the bistecca alla Fiorentina.

Good to know: Love Lauren Eldridge’s desserts? She does them across all four venues in the strip, and runs bake sales at Flora on Saturdays.

Advertisement

Good Food reviews are booked anonymously and paid independently. A restaurant can’t pay for a review or inclusion in the Good Food Guide.

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up

Continue this series

Inner West and Western Sydney
Up next
Wagyu tonnato.
  • Review

Postino Osteria

The kind of well-priced comfort food that every neighbourhood deserves.

The Rising Sun wachoushoku breakfast plate changes with the seasons.
  • Review

Rising Sun Workshop

Bikes, ramen and fine times in the backstreets.

Previously
Duck breast with pomegranate and marsala at Osteria di Russo & Russo
  • Review

Osteria di Russo & Russo

Old-world trattoria that also feels very now.

See all stories

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement