The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement
14.5/20Critics' Pick

Carnation Canteen

Updated ,first published

Inside Fitzroy’s Carnation Canteen.
1 / 9Inside Fitzroy’s Carnation Canteen.Bonnie Savage
Grilled whole King George whiting.
2 / 9Grilled whole King George whiting.Bonnie Savage
Breton custard cake.
3 / 9Breton custard cake.Bonnie Savage
A glowing beacon on a Fitzroy corner.
4 / 9A glowing beacon on a Fitzroy corner.Bonnie Savage
Matrimonio (white and red anchovies).
5 / 9Matrimonio (white and red anchovies).) at Carnation Canteen in Fitzroy Bonnie Savage
Visit from 4pm for martinis and apertivi.
6 / 9Visit from 4pm for martinis and apertivi.Visit from 4pm for aperitivi,
Chorizo at Carnation Canteen.
7 / 9Chorizo at Carnation Canteen.Bonnie Savage
Fresh salad.
8 / 9Fresh salad.Bonnie Savage
The charming 20 seat restaurant.
9 / 9The charming 20 seat restaurant.Coco and Maximilian
14.5/20Critics' Pick

Carnation Canteen

Contemporary$$

Glowing bijou beacon in a former corner store.

Chocolate mousse that’s mounded on the plate like mortar. Tissue-thin tuna cut with geometric edges to fit its barge of toast. Hand-scrawled menus that only experienced waitstaff can decipher. When you discover that chef-owner Audrey Shaw is a former architect, Carnation Canteen makes even more sense.

No item is superfluous, in the room or on the plate. Anchovies and black olives pony up to the smokiness of grilled greens. Somewhere between tartare and a rare burger, svizzerina is a patty of crisp-edged yet pink curls of chopped eye fillet, scooped onto bronzed toasts with a dab of confit garlic.

Bread-and-butter pudding rests, unadorned, in a lake of custard. Vases of poppies and pink roses bring a femme edge to the stark space, all steel-legged furniture, neat lines and walls that proudly show every scar they’ve endured. Minimalist? More like cool-eyed confidence.

Good to know: Several seats are backless stools, but outside you’re assured a chair.

Good Food reviews are booked anonymously and paid independently. A restaurant can’t pay for a review or inclusion in the Good Food Guide.

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up

Continue this series

Melbourne’s Northern Suburbs
Up next
Citrus buffet
  • Review

Citrus

A help-yourself curry hotspot.

Jamsheed’s converted industrial dining room.
  • Review

Clara Luna at Jamsheed

For happiness-inducing food and drink.

Previously
Carlton Wine Room is a favourite spot.
  • Review

Carlton Wine Room

A cosy corner hub keeping pace with its contemporaries.

See all stories

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement