The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement
Good Food hat15.5/20Critics' Pick

Neptune’s Grotto

Neptune’s Grotto’s horseshoe booths.
1 / 9Neptune’s Grotto’s horseshoe booths.Edwina Pickles
Tuna caponata.
2 / 9Tuna caponata.Edwina Pickles
Vitello anguillato.
3 / 9Vitello anguillato. Edwina Pickles
Tajarin pasta, made with extra egg yolk, are twisted through a fresh-tasting pomodoro sauce.
4 / 9Tajarin pasta, made with extra egg yolk, are twisted through a fresh-tasting pomodoro sauce.Edwina Pickles
Chopper liver crostini with chicken schmaltz.
5 / 9Chopper liver crostini with chicken schmaltz. Edwina Pickles
Cotolletta alla Milanese.
6 / 9Cotolletta alla Milanese. Edwina Pickles
A statue of Neptune sits in the middle of the room at Neptune’s Grotto.
7 / 9A statue of Neptune sits in the middle of the room at Neptune’s Grotto.Jason Loucas
Superba cocktail.
8 / 9Superba cocktail. Ethan Smart
Giardiniera pickled vegetables and pappa al pomodoro.
9 / 9Giardiniera pickled vegetables and pappa al pomodoro.Ethan Smart
Good Food hat15.5/20Critics' Pick

Neptune’s Grotto

Italian$$

Stylish subterranean restaurant made for lunching long and hard.

Neptune’s Grotto makes you pine for the era of the three-martini lunch – a time that facilitated all-day disappearances fuelled by expense accounts. Descend the stairs to this enclave beneath sibling restaurant Clam Bar, and outside-world responsibilities just slip away.

Wine man Andy Tyson and chefs Dan Pepperell and Mikey Clift have been vamping with every venue they touch, and this is the trio’s most romantic and Goodfellas-esque of the bunch. How’s that zebra-print carpet? Olives all’ascolana are perfect with that deathly cold gin cocktail, and marinated zucchini with mint vinaigrette is unexpectedly glorious.

Pork sausage gramigna pasta (the slightly twisty one) is extra lush, and there’s grandma-style pizza slices to scoop up the sauce. It’s a carb-on-carb manoeuvre, yes, but we feel that Neptune – who watches over the candlelit booths in life-sized statue form – would approve.

Must order: The perfectly thick and crunchy cotoletta alla Milanese.

Good Food reviews are booked anonymously and paid independently. A restaurant can’t pay for a review or inclusion in the Good Food Guide.

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up

Continue this series

Sydney CBD
Up next
Maremma duck, purple carrot, blackberry, madeira and macadamia.
  • Review

Oborozuki

Old-school flourishes aplenty, with harbour views.

A selection of premium seafood.
  • Review

Omakase by Prefecture 48

Luxurious omakase in a beautifully restored CBD heritage building.

Previously
Spring tart with comté, peas, asparagus and fine herbs at Morrison’s.
  • Review

Morrison’s

Bustling bistro that will put a smile on any dial.

See all stories

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement