The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement
14/20Critics' Pick

North Fitzroy Arms

Updated ,first published

The upmarket pie floater at the North Fitzroy Arms.
1 / 9The upmarket pie floater at the North Fitzroy Arms.Jana Langhorst
Crumbed garfish and chips.
2 / 9Crumbed garfish and chips.Supplied
The revamped dining room at the North Fitzroy Arms.
3 / 9The revamped dining room at the North Fitzroy Arms.Supplied
The cheeseburger.
4 / 9The cheeseburger.Jana Langhorst
Outside the iconic boozer.
5 / 9Outside the iconic boozer.Jana Langhorst
Inside the  dining room.
6 / 9Inside the dining room.Jana Langhorst
The North Fitzroy Arms’ schnitzel Holstein.
7 / 9The North Fitzroy Arms’ schnitzel Holstein.Supplied
Sausage rolls.
8 / 9Sausage rolls.Supplied
The beef, Guinness and marrow pie.
9 / 9The beef, Guinness and marrow pie.Penny Stephens
14/20Critics' Pick

North Fitzroy Arms

Pub dining$$

An upstanding member of Melbourne’s reborn corner boozer club.

Few pubs have dining rooms this romantic: wax cascading down silver candlesticks, tables covered with heavy linen, every face gorgeously lit. Staff bustle past in brown smocks (her) and chore coats (him), pulling Morgon gamay from temperature-controlled cabinets and changing heavy silver cutlery between courses. (And this is a place where you’ll want more than a counter meal.)

To start, chicken liver parfait for the high-minded, chunky sausage rolls for nostalgia hunters, sourdough focaccia for all. Pub purists will delight in a pair of stonking pork sausages, peppery and juicy and resting on baby-soft mash.

The pie is a pie floater, pureed peas the colour of grass all around. Its thick gravy unites crust with 12-hour-cooked beef cheek, and it’s served with buttery mash. One room away, the footy’s on, pool cues clack, pints are spilled: it’s the pub, deluxe edition.

Must-order: The espresso martini with Guinness is a very 2025 update to an enduring favourite.

Advertisement

Good Food reviews are booked anonymously and paid independently. A restaurant can’t pay for a review or inclusion in the Good Food Guide.

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up

Continue this series

Good Food Guide 2025: Melbourne’s top 20 pubs
Up next
  • Recommended

North Port Hotel

Regulars here know there’s more than beer and crumbed chook to be found.

The Frenchy light fittings of The Post Office Club Hotel in St Kilda.
  • Recommended

Post Office Club Hotel

A longstanding boozer serving steak specials and Guinness on tap.

Previously
Northcote Social Club.
  • Recommended

Northcote Social Club

A live music institution has no business serving food this good.

See all stories

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement