The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement
14/20Critics' Pick

North Fitzroy Arms

Updated ,first published

The upmarket pie floater at the North Fitzroy Arms.
1 / 9The upmarket pie floater at the North Fitzroy Arms.Jana Langhorst
Crumbed garfish and chips.
2 / 9Crumbed garfish and chips.Supplied
The revamped dining room at the North Fitzroy Arms.
3 / 9The revamped dining room at the North Fitzroy Arms.Supplied
The cheeseburger.
4 / 9The cheeseburger.Jana Langhorst
Outside the iconic boozer.
5 / 9Outside the iconic boozer.Jana Langhorst
Inside the  dining room.
6 / 9Inside the dining room.Jana Langhorst
The North Fitzroy Arms’ schnitzel Holstein.
7 / 9The North Fitzroy Arms’ schnitzel Holstein.Supplied
Sausage rolls.
8 / 9Sausage rolls.Supplied
The beef, Guinness and marrow pie.
9 / 9The beef, Guinness and marrow pie.Penny Stephens
14/20Critics' Pick

North Fitzroy Arms

Pub dining$$

An upstanding member of Melbourne’s reborn corner boozer club.

Few pubs have dining rooms this romantic: wax cascading down silver candlesticks, tables covered with heavy linen, every face gorgeously lit. Staff bustle past in brown smocks (her) and chore coats (him), pulling Morgon gamay from temperature-controlled cabinets and changing heavy silver cutlery between courses. (And this is a place where you’ll want more than a counter meal.)

To start, chicken liver parfait for the high-minded, chunky sausage rolls for nostalgia hunters, sourdough focaccia for all. Pub purists will delight in a pair of stonking pork sausages, peppery and juicy and resting on baby-soft mash.

The pie is a pie floater, pureed peas the colour of grass all around. Its thick gravy unites crust with 12-hour-cooked beef cheek, and it’s served with buttery mash. One room away, the footy’s on, pool cues clack, pints are spilled: it’s the pub, deluxe edition.

Must-order: The espresso martini with Guinness is a very 2025 update to an enduring favourite.

Advertisement

Good Food reviews are booked anonymously and paid independently. A restaurant can’t pay for a review or inclusion in the Good Food Guide.

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up

Continue this series

Melbourne’s Northern Suburbs
Up next
Choose your sichuan hot pot broth at Panda.
  • Review

Panda Hot Pot

Hotspot staged like a martial arts film set in ancient China.

Confetti supreme pizza with capsicum, button mushroom, sliced olives and spring onion.
  • Review

Pizzeria Magma

A low-lit, low-fi HQ for puff-crusted pizza.

Previously
Octopus salad.
  • Review

Norma

A heartwarming tribute to Euro comfort cooking.

See all stories

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement