The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement
14/20

The Dining Room

Paspaley pearl meat with persimmon and seablite.
1 / 8Paspaley pearl meat with persimmon and seablite.Sitthixay Ditthavong
Comfortable booths and spotlit tables are spaced among heritage pylons.
2 / 8Comfortable booths and spotlit tables are spaced among heritage pylons.Sitthixay Ditthavong
Carpaccio of octopus with sweet pickled fennel and spices.
3 / 8Carpaccio of octopus with sweet pickled fennel and spices.Sitthixay Ditthavong
Black Opal wagyu sirloin with smoked tallow jus.
4 / 8Black Opal wagyu sirloin with smoked tallow jus.Sitthixay Ditthavong
The Garden courtyard area.
5 / 8The Garden courtyard area.Sitthixay Ditthavong
Coral trout with ’nduja XO piperade.
6 / 8Coral trout with ’nduja XO piperade.Sitthixay Ditthavong
The Dining Room is a sympathetic refit of The Argyle nightclub.
7 / 8The Dining Room is a sympathetic refit of The Argyle nightclub.Sitthixay Ditthavong
The tables are generously spaced, but the room is cavernous.
8 / 8The tables are generously spaced, but the room is cavernous.Sitthixay Ditthavong
14/20

The Dining Room

Contemporary$$$

The flagship in The Collective is carving out a niche in The Rocks.

Finding an angle when the city is so flush with copy-paste luxury grills is a challenge, and although The Dining Room (in the refreshed bones of The Argyle) bills itself as a generalist, it certainly hits the tropes: a seafood bar, premium cuts, desserts promising childlike glee.

But that doesn’t mean what’s on the plate isn’t worth your time: a crudo of Paspaley pearl meat, strewn with super-ripe persimmon that slyly mimics the mollusc’s slippery texture; steaks of noble heritage, grilled attentively and rested just until the slices have iridescent sheen.

Meanwhile, the cellar’s stacked wall-to-wall with rare and prestigious bottles. The tables could be closer together, and the attention to detail in the whole show would only benefit from rising to meet the execution in the kitchen, but there’s plenty here to enjoy, especially if you swing past cocktail bar the Tailor Room after dinner.

Good to know: Steak and eggs for brekkie or a build-it-yourself burger for lunch in The Garden is an open secret worth being in on.

Good Food reviews are booked anonymously and paid independently. A restaurant can’t pay for a review or inclusion in the Good Food Guide.

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up

Continue this series

Sydney CBD
Up next
Key lime pie.
  • Review

Eleven Barrack

Neo-classic New York-style grill with Sydney flair.

A parilla grill and vertical rotisserie fire the menu at Esteban.
  • Review

Esteban

Subterranean parilla where agave is king.

Previously
The Dining Room by James Viles offers a crash course in Australian cuisine.
  • Review

The Dining Room by James Viles

Hyper-seasonal produce with shimmering Sydney Harbour views.

See all stories

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement