The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement
Good Food hat15/20

Smith St Bistrot

Updated ,first published

Find souffle and other French standards here.
1 / 9Find souffle and other French standards here.Alex Squadrito.
Outside the Collingwood restaurant.
2 / 9Outside the Collingwood restaurant.Alex Squadrito
Grilled flounder with warm sauce gribiche.
3 / 9Grilled flounder with warm sauce gribiche.Alex Squadrito
Creme caramel.
4 / 9Creme caramel.Alex Squadrito
Chicken fricassee.
5 / 9Chicken fricassee.Chris Hopkins
Tartare de thon.
6 / 9Tartare de thon.Chris Hopkins
Scott Pickett’s Smith Street restaurant.
7 / 9Scott Pickett’s Smith Street restaurant.Alex Squadrito
Vol au vent escargot.
8 / 9Vol au vent escargot.Chris Hopkins
Lobster thermidor.
9 / 9Lobster thermidor.Alex Squadrito
Good Food hat15/20

Smith St Bistrot

French$$

Scott Pickett’s ode to 1920s Paris.

Stepping from gritty Smith Street into this Gallic mise en scene is like a warm embrace. Brasserie design details abound: smoky mirrors, marble-topped tables, dangling copper pots, velvet-cushioned bentwood bar stools. Throw in a wrought-iron spiral staircase and curved burgundy banquettes and even fervent Francophiles are satisfied.

The menu, meanwhile, marries classical cooking with playful twists. Coquilles Saint-Jacques, for example, pack a hint of curry in the scallops’ buttery sauce and a gentle crunch from puffed rice. Steak au poivre matches tender wagyu rostbiff with finely chopped mushrooms and cognac-spiked peppercorn sauce.

And oh-so-Australian Humpty Doo barramundi gets a French makeover, bathing in smoked butter sauce studded with salmon roe and tiny potatoes. Service is warm, if sometimes patchy, but all is forgiven with a textbook creme caramel, on the menu since day one.

Good to know: Monthly jazz nights in the upstairs private room offer dinner and a show for $95.

Good Food reviews are booked anonymously and paid independently. A restaurant can’t pay for a review or inclusion in the Good Food Guide.

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up

Continue this series

Melbourne’s Northern Suburbs
Up next
Pasta is all served in takeaway boxes at Super Norma.
  • Review

Super Norma

A cosy-cool pasta bar with the energy of Nonna’s house.

Marinated peppers with curry leaf and house-baked focaccia.
  • Review

Suze

A beacon of quiet luxury on a serene backstreet.

Previously
Smith & Daughters has relaunched with a casual dining menu.
  • Review

Smith & Daughters Social Club

Funfair-style fare in an expansive warehouse.

See all stories

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement