The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement
14/20Critics' Pick

Builders Arms Hotel

Updated ,first published

Old meets new at the Builders Arms Hotel on Gertrude Street.
1 / 9Old meets new at the Builders Arms Hotel on Gertrude Street.Supplied
The Builders Arms fish pie is a year-round favourite.
2 / 9The Builders Arms fish pie is a year-round favourite.Justin McManus
Inside the Builders Arms Hotel in Fitzroy.
3 / 9Inside the Builders Arms Hotel in Fitzroy.Photograph by Chris Hopkins
Sausage rolls.
4 / 9Sausage rolls.Photograph by Chris Hopkins
Builders Arms’ rotating rotisserie chicken special.
5 / 9Builders Arms’ rotating rotisserie chicken special.Parker Blain
Beef cheek croquettes.
6 / 9Beef cheek croquettes.Supplied
Crumbed fish bun.
7 / 9Crumbed fish bun.Supplied
Whipped cod roe.
8 / 9Whipped cod roe.Kate Shanasy
Cheeseburger.
9 / 9Cheeseburger.Jo McGann
14/20Critics' Pick

Builders Arms Hotel

Pub dining$$

The gold standard for ever-so-fancy pubs with reliable food.

The Builders offers the best things about your corner local – beer on tap, sport on the telly and weekly specials – then dials up the glamour in the rear dining room with food that’s a cut above most pubs in town.

There are dishes that will never leave the menu – the emoji-like potato bun cheeseburger with golden fries, the oversized fish pie brimming with goldband snapper, trout and prawns – but there are also surprises to be found. A brilliantly hued tumble of heritage beetroot with creamy stracciatella; a virtuous side of chopped broccoli tossed with freekeh, almond and snipped herbs; and a dome of sticky date pudding with rivers of butterscotch sauce and fresh cream.

The place is perpetually packed and slightly on the pricey side (hello $110 club steak), but you can bring anyone – from a promising date to a fussy grandparent – and they’ll be content.

Must-order: Whipped cod roe dip with grassy olive oil and fingers of toasted flatbread.

Good Food reviews are booked anonymously and paid independently. A restaurant can’t pay for a review or inclusion in the Good Food Guide.

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

Sign up

Continue this series

Good Food Guide 2025: Melbourne’s top 20 pubs
Up next
The garden marquee at the Flying Duck Hotel.
  • Recommended

Flying Duck Hotel

Slip into a green leather booth or perch in the fairy-lit glasshouse at this rejuvenated 1868 beauty.

Hardimans Hotel.
  • Recommended

Hardimans Hotel

The rowdy courtyard at this multi-level space is a go-to for summer sessions.

Previously
The freshly renovated Beehive Hotel in Hawthorn.
  • Recommended

The Beehive Hotel

An old beacon with a cheffy new menu.

See all stories

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement