Match report: Cleary breaks down again as Panthers hold off Bulldogs
By Billie Eder
Panthers star Nathan Cleary will be sent for scans, possibly as early as Saturday morning, after aggravating a hamstring injury during Friday night’s 16-10 victory against the Bulldogs at BlueBet Stadium.
“He’s pretty shattered, actually. It’s very disappointing for him, obviously I’m sort of torn between [being] his coach and his dad,” Panthers coach Ivan Cleary said.
“Very disappointing, especially I thought that first half he was really starting to come into his own, but anyway, the show goes on. Just have to get a scan and see the damage and then we’ll go from there. He felt it straight away, so he knew. That would suggest it’s decent [significant].”
The coach said the injury hadn’t been an issue for a fortnight, which is why the halfback played against the Cowboys two weeks ago.
“It hasn’t been a problem. He came back [from injury], he played against the Cowboys, he didn’t play last week because it was a five-day turnaround, he was a bit sore,” Ivan said. “So that was always part of the threat, I guess, of travelling ... he’s basically done every session for two weeks without any drama.”
It’s a nightmare scenario for Blues coach Michael Maguire, with Cameron Murray, Mitchell Moses, Clint Gutherson and Ryan Papenhuyzen also on the injured list less than a month before the State of Origin opener on June 15.
Nathan Cleary leaves the field on Friday night after aggravating his hamstring injury.NRL Photos
Cleary left the field two minutes before half-time after kicking a grubber to force a goal-line dropout. He was then seen consulting one of the Panthers’ trainers before heading up the tunnel. It’s the same hamstring that kept him sidelined for a month earlier in the season.
When the Panthers came out for the second half, Jack Cole combined with Jarome Luai in the halves and Dylan Edwards took over conversion duties.
Panthers coach Cleary will head into Magic Round in Brisbane next week without his first two picks at halfback, after back-up half Brad Schneider injured his knee in their NSW Cup game on Friday.
The Bulldogs were impressive in defeat, with Cameron Ciraldo’s team holding Penrith scoreless for the opening 25 minutes.
Brian To’o scored just before half-time to give the home side a 12-point lead, before Matt Burton finally broke through for Canterbury with a try in the 68th minute.
Jacob Kiraz went over for the Bulldogs’ second try with just five seconds left, but two penalty goals for the Panthers in the second half had provided enough breathing room to hold off the visitors.
“We came here confident, but I think we’re leaving probably even more confident,” Ciraldo said.
The Panthers play the Warriors in Brisbane next Sunday.
7.46pm on May 10, 2024
Full-time: Panthers 16-10
By
80 min: Kiraz spins out of a few tackles to score in the corner after sustained Bulldogs pressure. Burton converts from the sideline. Panthers win 16-10
7.40pm on May 10, 2024
Panthers in front by 12 again
By
76 min: Former Panther Kikau infringes in the ruck and another Edwards penalty goal gives the home side an unassailable 12-point lead. Panthers 16-4
69 min: Burton gives the Dogs a sniff by beating former Bulldog Alamoti to score close to the line. Burton misses the kick. Panthers 14-4
7.25pm on May 10, 2024
View from the ground
By
7.19pm on May 10, 2024
Dogs denied
By
58 min: Addo-Carr crosses but the final pass from Xerri is correctly ruled forward. The Dogs desperately needed to score there. Panthers 14-0
Advertisement
7.13pm on May 10, 2024
Panthers extend their lead
By
53 min: Penrith, chasing seven straight wins against the Bulldogs, go ahead by more than two converted tries thanks to an Edwards penalty goal. Panthers 14-0
7.09pm on May 10, 2024
Cole comfort
By
48 min: No Cleary, no worries for Penrith – so far. Jack Cole performing solidly in his place. Canterbury need to be next to score to have a hope in this match.
7.00pm on May 10, 2024
Game back on
By
41 min: Canterbury and Penrith return to the field, but Cleary’s night is over. Jack Cole is his replacement. Huge shoes to fill.