The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement

This was published 5 months ago

Taylor Swift Life of a Showgirl as it happened: US singer-songwriter releases 12th studio album, says ‘album just feels so right’ in Instagram post

Nell Geraets and Lauren Ironmonger
Updated ,first published
Pinned post from 5.01pm on Oct 3, 2025
Go to latest

Bye Bye Baby, until the next era!

By Nell Geraets
Show’s over, folks.Instagram

Well, honey, we’re out of the woods. I hope you got everything that was on your wish list and that your opinions of Showgirl haven’t ruined any friendships. Please tell me you picked up those puns...

Thank you so much for joining us on this rollercoaster ride that is a Taylor Swift album launch. We were enchanted to have you along for the journey.

If you’re still hungry for more content, you can read Giselle Au-Nhien Nguyen’s review here. You can also read a full track-by-track breakdown on this blog, and don’t forget to choose your favourite Showgirl track in our poll, which is pinned up top!

Now, enjoy listening to the album on repeat, and we’ll see you in the next era!

Pinned post from 2.49pm on Oct 3, 2025
Go to latest

What is your favourite song on the new album?

By
Pinned post from 2.03pm on Oct 3, 2025
Go to latest

Our critic’s verdict on The Life of a Showgirl

By

Here’s what music critic Giselle Au-Nhien Nguyen has to say about The Life of a Showgirl:

The Life of a Showgirl notably marks the return of Max Martin and Shellback, the Swedish pop masterminds who produced and co-wrote with Swift from 2012’s Red to 2017’s Reputation. Since then, Swift has worked extensively with Jack Antonoff and Aaron Dessner, building a sonic palette that has, over time, come to feel predictable. I’d venture to say Swift’s last truly great record was 2020’s indie-inflected folklore, which heralded a new sonic and lyrical approach; her most recent album, 2024’s The Tortured Poets Department, was overstuffed and uneven.

Martin’s pedigree – including decades of hits from the Backstreet Boys and Britney Spears to Katy Perry and Lady Gaga – is evident in the stronger earworms such as Opalite and Honey. Wood, questionable lyrics aside, could easily be a Carly Rae Jepsen track. These are decent pop songs, but they don’t hold a candle to Swift and Martin’s joint best, like 2014’s New Romantics.

Even Martin’s legendary skill doesn’t make this a great pop record. For the most part, most of Swift’s signature bridges are gone, which were often the most fascinating and creative aspect of her songwriting. Instead, these perfectly pleasant songs largely blend seamlessly into the broader musical landscape without much differentiation.

Read the full review here.

Pinned post from 11.31am on Oct 3, 2025
Go to latest

Welcome to the show(girl)… Ready for it?

By Nell Geraets

Hello and welcome to our Life of a Showgirl blog! We’re “enchanted” to have you (yes, prepare yourself for many Swift puns).

Swifties across the globe have been eagerly awaiting this moment since the pop juggernaut blew our minds by announcing her new album on a sports podcast in August. Who knew we’d be back again so soon after pulling off the millions of friendship bracelets we collected at the Eras Tour?

Well, Taylor did. In fact, she’s been dropping Easter eggs left, right and centre since her tour (anyone remember the orange door at her final show?).

Regardless of whether you saw it coming or not, here we are, ready for another 12 songs! Knowing Swift “all too well”, there will probably be a few extra surprises thrown in there. But worry not because we’re here to update you every step of the way.

So… Ready for it?

Latest Posts

What The Life of a Showgirl taught us about Taylor

By Nell Geraets

We’ve laughed, some of us may have cried, we’ve all definitely boogied and bopped. The Life of a Showgirl is now officially out in the world, and there’s a fair bit to take in.

While this album felt a little less like a glimpse into Taylor’s personal diary compared to some of her other albums, it still taught us a few key things about her current state of mind, and also indicated a few new names on her blacklist...

Let’s go over the five main takeaways.

She’s a happy gal now!

Move over Tortured Poets Department because this singer is shouting her joy from the rooftops. The sorrowful, heart-wrenching, introspective tracks that have defined her discography over the past few years seem like distant memory in contrast to new titles like Opalite and Wi$h Li$t.

Nicki Minaj is having a great time, but has someone checked on Travis?

By Lauren Ironmonger

Given his fiancé just wrote a whole album about him, including a glowing review of his, erm, wood, you’d think Travis Kelce would be able to muster at least a few words of congratulations for Swift on social media. Obviously, Kelce doesn’t have to make his thoughts public, but given the pair have built an entire brand on their partnership, you’d think he’d have at least scheduled a post...

So far, all we’ve seen is a slightly lame post on Kelce’s podcast account referencing Mean Girls.

Elsewhere, Nicki Minaj has taken a break from her escalating social media feud with Cardi B to share her (many) thoughts about the album.

Minaj’s flurry of tweets include: “Oh Taylor #WOOD was EXACTLY what I needed tonight. Thank you,” and “And now…The Sagittarius lashing spree culminates with The Life Of A Showgirl,” followed by “GO IN FOR THE KILL, TAYLOR. LET’S GO!!!!”

Sabrina Carpenter (who features on The Life of a Showgirl’s final track) also showed some love on Instagram, posting, “I love you Taylor”.

‘He’s a real vibes guy’: Swift talks about Kelce in first proper media interview

By Lauren Ironmonger

Kicking off a week of media appearances, Swift has sat down with BBC Radio 1 presenter Greg James to chat about the new album.

James, who has interviewed Swift multiple times over the years, was chummy with the singer, laughing about inside jokes and whether he would get an invitation to the wedding. Swift also brought James a loaf of sourdough bread, explaining baking has been occupying her time since wrapping up the Eras tour.

“I have such uncomplicated feelings of joy for it,” Swift said of The Life of a Showgirl, “with this album my life is in exactly the same spot as when I wrote the record”.

Swift also spoke of Kelce’s involvement as a sounding board for the record.

Advertisement

A guide to Taylor Swift’s references in Elizabeth Taylor

By With AP

For Taylor Swift’s most dedicated audience, a new album means new opportunities to decode Easter eggs in her lyrics and music videos. The pop superstar’s 12th studio album has no shortage of clever clues and references to her public life and discography. Many are opaque, revealing just enough to inspire a myriad of fan theories. Others are concrete – explicit names and places worth exploring. Let’s unpack her song Elizabeth Taylor.

Elizabeth Taylor, New York, 1964. Richard Avedon

Lyric: That view of Portofino was on my mind / When you called me at the Plaza Athénée
Meaning: When Swift announced her new album, she did so with the introduction of a shade she’s calling Portofino Orange Glitter after donning the colour onstage during the latter part of her Eras Tour. “I’ve just always liked it,” she said of the hue during her first appearance on New Heights, the popular, typically football-focused podcast hosted by her fiancé Travis Kelce and his brother, Jason Kelce. “It feels like energetically how my life has felt. And this album is about what was going on behind the scenes in my inner life during this tour.” She and beau Kelce were spotted last year in Lake Como, Italy, but it is unclear if they spent time in nearby Portofino. Additionally, the standard version of her album is available in “sweat and vanilla perfume Portofino orange vinyl.” As for the Plaza Athénée? That’s a luxury hotel in Paris.

Lyric: Be my NY when Hollywood hates me
Meaning: Both locations make appearances in Swift’s songwriting. Among them: Welcome to New York from 2014’s 1989 and White Horse from 2008’s Fearless. She also owns property in both locations.

Late-night talk shows, radio, cinema screenings: What’s with all the promo?

By Nell Geraets

Taylor Swift is one of those artists who doesn’t really need any kind of thorough promotional campaign ahead of an album release. Her fandom is so massive and so loyal that she would probably still break sales records even if she just suddenly released new tracks via Instagram, no lead-up whatsoever.

So, why is she so booked and busy this time around?

Over the next week, the pop juggernaut will appear on not just one, but three late-night talk shows – The Graham Norton Show, The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon and Late Night with Seth Meyers. She’s also going to join various radio stations, including BBC Radio 1, Magic Heart, Capital Breakfast and Hits Radio Breakfast Show.

Then there are all the Official Release Party of a Showgirl cinema screenings across the globe, the seemingly endless album poster iterations, and, of course, the themed cardigan and other forms of merch that are already on-sale via her website.

Before announcing the album on the sports podcast New Heights, Swift hadn’t done a long-form interview with media since Time Magazine in 2023. But she seems to be going harder in the marketing for Showgirl than she normally would.

To all the boys she’s ever loved, prepare to be haunted

By Nell Geraets

It’s not every day that a new Taylor Swift album drops during spooky season, and one Swiftie is taking full advantage of that.

To welcome both Halloween and The Life of a Showgirl, a very creative fan has decorated the stairs to their brownstone townhouse with the headstones of all of Swift’s past lovers – Matty Healy, Joe Alwyn, Jake Gyllenhaal, you name it, their grave is on display.

Above them is a very flamboyant skeleton Taylor Swift and a much less bulky Travis Kelce dressed in his Kansas City Chiefs jersey. It appears they’re having a grand old time over the corpses of her exes.

Over to the right is a special display all for Scooter Braun, arguably Swift’s arch-nemesis (she had to buy her music back from him – it was a whole messy ordeal). Skeleton Braun is dressed in what appears to be an orange (perfect for Showgirl!) prison jumpsuit, and he’s trapped in a cage. Quite the statement, but Swift has never been known for being subtle either, so it suits.

Advertisement

A bridge too far?

By Nell Geraets

Before you begin to panic that there are no bridges in The Life of a Showgirl, take a deep breath – there are bridges. This is a Taylor Swift album, after all.

They are a little different, though. Swift is known for powerful bridges in her songs, largely because they often act as emotional catalysts or a crucial turning point in the track’s tone. Take the one in All Too Well (10 Minute Version):

Well, maybe we got lost in translation, maybe I asked for too much
But maybe this thing was a masterpiece ’til you tore it all up
Runnin’ scared, I was there
I remember it all too well
And you call me up again just to break me like a promise
So casually cruel in the name of bein’ honest
I’m a crumpled-up piece of paper lyin’ here
’Cause I remember it all, all, all.

Her previous album, The Tortured Poets Department, was also filled with lengthy, emotionally raw bridges, particularly in songs like The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived. She’s ultimately a lyricist, and she’s here to craft a story.

Taylor Swift performing during her Eras Tour at Accor Stadium, Sydney in 2024.Wolter Peeters

How have critics received the album?

By Lauren Ironmonger

One only needs to turn to social media to see that Swifties around the world are loving The Life of a Showgirl. But how is it being received by the experts?

If you haven’t already, make sure to read our music critic Giselle Au-Nhien Nguyen’s verdict on the album.

Now, let’s take a look at what some other critics around the world are saying:

  • The New York Times: Pop music critic Jon Caramanica drew parallels between Showgirl and Reputation, of all Swift’s previous works, viewing the album as “an implicit capstone to Taylor Swift’s career to date, as several significant narratives come to a conclusion.” But ultimately, he sees it as a confused, decentred work. “Showgirl has hints of what a Swift album about requited love might sound like, but for now, she’s not quite over the taste of blood,” he concludes his review with.
  • The Guardian: Head pop and rock critic Alexis Petridis doled out a measly two stars to The Life of a Showgirl, commenting on the album’s “distinct lack of undeniable hooks and nailed-on melodies”, save for Elizabeth Taylor. “It’s just nowhere near as good as it should be given Swift’s talents, and it leaves you wondering why. Perhaps romantic contentment simply writes whiter than vengeful post-breakup bitterness, or perhaps it wobbles your judgment,” Petridis writes.
  • Variety: Chief music critic Chris Wilma, had plenty of criticisms, but was overwhelmingly positive. “It’s too late for Swift to have a ‘song of the summer,’ but this feels like the Album of the Summer – the calendar be damned. It’s giddy, funny, touching, silly, haughty and moving in about equal measure, but most of all, it’s got a sunstruck kind of love that besottedly seeps through the orange LP grooves and might even make you believe in romance again, too,” he wrote.
  • Rolling Stone: Assistant editor Maya Georgi gave the album a gushing five-star review, writing: “Only a sucker would think the curtain close of the Eras Tour marked the end of Swift’s almighty reign in the pop sphere. With her 12th studio album, the musician shoots into a fresh echelon of superstardom – and hits all her marks.”
  • Billboard: Executive director of music Jason Lipshutz was similarly praiseful, writing that “The limit does not exist to how high Swift can keep soaring… The Life of a Showgirl is one of the most grounded, well-rounded projects of Swift’s career – a surprise, in the context of the hype preceding it. That doesn’t make it any less successful.”

A critic picks the standout song

By

Music critic Tom W. Clarke has picked his favourite song from the album. Vote for yours in the poll above, and tell us why in the comments.

The Life of a Showgirl is, more than anything, a love letter. Taylor Swift is the world’s greatest pop star, fresh off the biggest world tour in history, and is newly engaged to a man who seems to adore her, after years of having her love life under a microscope. She’s happy, and it’s beautiful. The album overflows with joy – at turns wistful, nostalgic, playfully acerbic, and carefree.

But best of all, it means we get Wood – the most uncharacteristically sex-forward song Taylor Swift has ever released, and an absolute jam. From the moment that funky, twisting, almost Prince-esque guitar kicks in, it’s clear this is a groove for the boudoir.

If this album is about love, Wood is pure lust, the kind of ravenous desire that only comes from being with someone who makes you feel safe and seen and sexy as hell. It’s funny, and surprising, double entendre out the wazoo. It could so easily have been cringey, but it couldn’t sound more easy and natural. This is the most fun Taylor Swift has sounded in a hot minute, and it’s so great.

Advertisement