The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement
WorldNorth AmericaUS Votes 2024

This was published 1 year ago

US election 2024 as it happened: Donald Trump takes to the stage at New York rally; positive polls for Harris

Paul Sakkal
Updated ,first published

Key Posts

Where will Trump and Harris campaign tomorrow?
Harris slams Trump as ‘unstable, unhinged’
Democrats beam anti-Trump messages onto Madison Square Garden
Trump sells message of ‘hope’ before attacking enemies
Elon Musk pleads with voters to turn out
Rally mania causes havoc in New York
Harris targets patriots, disaffected Republicans, Gen Z
Trump to hold major rally at iconic NY venue
Latest polls have good news for Harris

Wrapping up

By

Thank you for joining our live coverage of the US presidential election, which is entering its final stages ahead of polling day on November 5.

The big moment of the day was Donald Trump’s rally in Madison Square Garden – described by a top Trump adviser as the “centre of the universe” – at which Elon Musk, Hulk Hogan, and Trump’s wife Melania gave the Republican a huge pump-up in an event resembling a campaign launch.

Elon Musk and Melania Trump watch Donald Trump speak at Madison Square Garden.AP

Trump largely stuck to script, beginning with a message of hope before deriding his enemies and speaking in dark tones about the state of the nation.

A comedian at the rally made offensive jokes about Latinos and Arab Americans, which were immediately latched onto by Kamala Harris’ campaign.

Trump’s ‘hidden supporters’ rally in New York as election hits final stretch

By Michael Koziol

New York: Though he is now a “Florida man”, Donald Trump is still a product of New York City.

The property mogul was once again an agent of chaos in his former home town – a city he now derides as dirty, unsafe and “failing” – when he returned for a blockbuster rally at Madison Square Garden that has been likened to a pro-Nazi protest from 1939.

Donald and Melania Trump at the rally at Madison Square Garden.AP

Packed with celebrities ranging from retired pro wrestler Hulk Hogan to tech billionaire Elon Musk and UFC boss Dana White, Trump billed the event as a celebration of the campaign, which has just over a week to run, with polls essentially deadlocked.

Outside the arena, streets were closed, traffic was backed up, sirens blared and people in outrageous costumes shouted on the sidewalk. None of these are unusual in New York, where you have to be brash and loud just to be heard.

Read Michael Koziol’s full piece, on the ground in New York, here.

Trump’s Madison Square Garden event features crude and racist insults

By

Donald Trump hosted a rally featuring crude and racist insults at New York’s Madison Square Garden on Sunday (Monday AEDT), turning what his campaign had dubbed as the event where he would deliver his closing message into an illustration of what turns off his critics.

With just over a week before election day, speakers labelled Puerto Rico a “floating island of garbage”, called Democratic Vice President Kamala Harris “the devil”, and said the woman vying to become America’s first female president had begun her career as a prostitute.

“I don’t know if you guys know this, but there’s literally a floating island of garbage in the middle of the ocean right now. I think it’s called Puerto Rico,” said Tony Hinchcliffe, a stand-up comic whose set also included lewd and racist comments about Latinos, Jews and black people, all key constituencies in the election just nine days away.

A vendor shows merchandise in support of Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump.AP

His joke was immediately criticised by Harris’ campaign as it competes with Trump to win over Puerto Rican communities in Pennsylvania and other swing states. Puerto Rican music superstar Bad Bunny backed Harris shortly after Hinchcliffe’s appearance.

Advertisement

What haunted Gillard stalks Harris, and it’s not just sexism

By Sean Kelly

Two weeks into the 2010 election campaign, Labor was in trouble. Partly as a circuit-breaker, Julia Gillard announced that from then on, voters would see the “real” Julia. “I’m going to discard all of that campaign advice and professional or common wisdom, and just go for it,” she said.

Gillard was slammed. If voters hadn’t been seeing the “real” her, who had they been seeing? Which was a reasonable question, except that many of those asking it had been criticising her for keeping her real self under wraps. She was damned either way.

Kamala Harris, like Julia Gillard, is finding that, as a woman, she is held to a different standard.AP/Alex Ellinghausen

Really, these apparently contradictory criticisms were just different expressions of the same underlying suspicion: that there was something false or concealed about our first female prime minister. It’s worth noting her opponent, Tony Abbott, was subjected to some of the same complaints about restraint – though in his case it was often praised, too, as “discipline”.

This theme followed Gillard through her prime ministership: the idea that she was not showing herself; that something was fundamentally opaque. When she did not show “enough” emotion, she was called “wooden”; when she became either upset or angry, she was attacked for confecting such things for political gain.

Read Sean Kelly’s full column here.

Where will Trump and Harris campaign tomorrow?

By

With the day coming to an end in the US, both presidential candidates have wrapped up their public campaign events ahead of next week’s election.

Here is what we can expect tomorrow, according to schedules released by each side:

  • Kamala Harris and her vice presidential candidate Tim Walz will hold a joint rally in Ann Arbor, in the key swing state of Michigan.
  • Walz will stop over in Wisconsin, another important seat in the so-called Rust Belt, which refers to a group of states that used to rely on heavy industry such as steel manufacturing.
  • Donald Trump will hold a rally in Atlanta, Georgia, where polls show the Republican has a slight edge.
  • Trump’s running mate J.D. Vance will also be in Wisconsin.

In the ultimate battle of the sexes in the most visceral of elections, who will prevail?

By Maureen Dowd

Usually, I get political wisdom from Rahm Emanuel, not his brother Ari.

But a quote from Ari, the Hollywood macher, about the gender chasm in 2024 caught my eye.

“This election is gonna come down to probably 120,000 votes,” Ari said. “You probably have 60 per cent of the male vote for Trump, and the female vote is 60-40 for Kamala. It’s a jump ball. We’re gonna find out who wants this more – men or women.”

Kamala Harris and Donald Trump are nearly tied in polling.AP

Are we back to the days of Mars versus Venus? Or did we never leave?

Advertisement

Trump thanks New York mayor for avoiding fascist label

By

In his widely televised address, Donald Trump thanked Democratic New York Mayor Eric Adams for saying he didn’t believe the Trump was a fascist.

Debate over the label was set off when Trump’s former chief of staff John Kelly told The New York Times he believed Trump “certainly falls into the general definition of fascist”.

New York Mayor Eric Adams was indicted last month on federal corruption charges.AP

The Britannica dictionary defines fascism, which grew to prominence in the early 20th century in Europe, as, “a way of organising a society in which a government ruled by a dictator controls the lives of the people and in which people are not allowed to disagree with the government”.

Harris said last week said she believed Trump was a fascist.

Harris slams Trump as ‘unstable, unhinged’

By

Kamala Harris has described Donald Trump as unstable after a long and rambling address to supporters at Madison Square Garden.

The New York event – featuring Elon Musk, Hulk Hogan and Trump’s wife, Melania – is being viewed as a campaign launch-style set piece designed to build momentum as the race entered its final stretch.

View post on X

Trump said his message was one of “hope” as he reached out to Arab and Latino voters in what loomed as a tight election on November 5.

But he repeated discredited claims on immigration, described his opponents as “enemies from within”, labelled Harris “low IQ”, and said he would let former independent candidate for president, Robert F. Kennedy Jr – a leading opponent of COVID-19 vaccines – “go wild on health and medicines” in a second Trump administration.

After the speech littered with dark themes about the state of American democracy, Harris said, “Donald Trump is increasingly unstable and unhinged.”

“He is seeking unchecked power in his second term, he has promised retribution and jail time for his political opponents, and he has violated his oath to uphold the Constitution of the United States,” she said on X.

Trump, Harris target Arab American voters

By Farrah Tomazin

Trump just spoke about the wide electoral coalition he says he is building, and highlighted Arab American and Muslim communities.

Yesterday he was in Michigan, the Midwest swing state where Kamala Harris faces a serious challenge due to the Biden-Harris administration’s stance over the war in Gaza.

I spent some time here last week, speaking to Arab Americans in the suburb of Dearborn, on the outskirts of Detroit, created by generations of migrants drawn to the area to work in the auto industry. The ongoing anger is palpable.

“These people, by the way, they’re great,” Trump said. “They just want peace. They want to have peace. Muslims and Catholics and evangelicals and Mormons, and they’re all joining our cause in large numbers, larger than anyone has ever seen in this country before.”

Read this masthead’s feature story on how Arab Americans might vote here.

Trump has now wrapped up his stump speech.

Advertisement

Democrats beam anti-Trump messages onto Madison Square Garden

By Farrah Tomazin

As Trump makes his case to voters in the final stretch of the campaign, the Democratic National Committee is projecting images on Madison Square Garden saying: “Trump = Unhinged” and “Trump = unfit”.

DNC chairman Jaime Harrison said: “Donald Trump has grown increasingly unhinged in the final weeks heading into election day; so much so that those who know Trump best are warning voters that he is dangerously unfit to lead.”

The DNC projects a message reading “Trump = Unhinged” onto Madison Square Garden.Getty Images

“Trump has been clear he wants to rule as an authoritarian, praising dictators including even Adolf Hitler, and threatening to unleash the US military on American citizens, who he refers to as ‘the enemy within’.”

The Democrat move comes after former White House chief of staff John Kelly described Trump as a fascist who reportedly “wanted the kind of generals Hitler had”.

Advertisement