The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement

This was published 7 months ago

How much of Gaza is left standing? True toll may be even greater than official reports suggest

The Economist

From above, much of Gaza appears flattened. But the full scale of the destruction and the number of people killed remain uncertain.

Daily death tolls are issued by local authorities run by Hamas, the Islamist group that still controls parts of the strip, but many doubt their accuracy. Foreign journalists are barred unless embedded with Israeli forces. In the absence of access, independent researchers have turned to satellite images, surveys and public records to estimate what has been lost.

Their findings suggest the toll may be even greater than suggested by official reports.

The physical damage has been assessed both by what has been destroyed and by the rubble that remains. The first method tracks changes to building outlines in satellite images over time.

Advertisement

Using this method, UNOSAT, a UN agency, identified damage to more than 190,000 buildings by early April – roughly 70 per cent of Gaza’s pre-war structures.

Of these, some 102,000 appear to have been completely destroyed. The World Bank reckons that translates to roughly 300,000 homes lost, including 77 per cent of all apartment buildings.

The second approach models how much debris a building of a given size would leave behind if destroyed. The most recent analysis by UN Habitat, another agency, estimated that 53.5 million tonnes of rubble now lie across the strip, a 133 per cent increase in 15 months.

Photo: The Economist
Advertisement

That has left few havens. Before the war, Gaza’s two million residents, half of them children, lived in 365 square kilometres – a population density similar to Madrid.

But by July 30, Israeli militarised zones and displacement had pushed the population into just 12.7 per cent of the strip, where many now live in tents.

That may be one of the most densely packed places on Earth.

Displaced Palestinians return to the war-devastated Jabalia refugee camp in the northern Gaza Strip on January 19.AFP

The collapse of medical care, sanitation and food supplies has caused thousands of deaths not directly tied to bombs or bullets.

Advertisement

A study by Michael Spagat, of Royal Holloway University of London, and others estimated that by January 5, between 4500 and 12,500 people had died from indirect causes.

The same study put the number of violent deaths at roughly 60,000 to 90,000 – more than half of them women, children, or men over the age of 65 (see chart).

Photo: The Economist

Another study estimated that 55,000 to 79,000 Gazans had died from traumatic injuries by the end of June 2024.

These independent estimates far exceed official counts, which reached 38,000 in June 2024 and 47,500 in January 2025.

Advertisement

If you assume that the ratio between the official figures and the academic estimates has remained the same, it would imply that four to five per cent of the territory’s pre-war population has now been killed.

The broader demographic toll is hard to grasp.

The studies imply that estimated life expectancy has fallen by more than 35 years, to roughly half the pre-war figure.

Loading

Advertisement

In percentage terms, this drop is bigger than the one recorded during China’s Great Leap Forward; in absolute terms, it is similar to the one following the Rwanda genocide.

For the civilians who have survived, the outlook is bleak.

Few basic services are running.

By August 1, the UN found that 76 per cent of schools had been directly hit by strikes. Around 95 per cent of hospitals have been significantly damaged.

Advertisement

The cost of rebuilding is still uncertain, but huge.

In February, the World Bank put it at roughly $US53 billion ($81 billion) – more than twice the combined pre-war GDP of Gaza and the West Bank.

A full reckoning will be possible only once the fighting ends. But the patchy data available suggests that this is among the most destructive conflicts in recent history.

The Economist

For the story behind the headlines, listen to The Morning Edition, with a new episode live every weekday from 5am. You can find The Morning Edition on Apple, Spotify, and everywhere you listen to your podcasts.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement