The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement
COMMENTWorld

This was published 8 years ago

Can you keep a secret, Mr Trump?

Daniel Flitton

Updated ,first published

Malcolm Turnbull sounded unfazed on Tuesday after explosive reports Donald Trump bragged about highly classified secrets of an ally during a meeting with Russia's Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov.

The US alliance remains the "bedrock" of Australia's security, Turnbull declared - just as have a dozen serving prime ministers before him.

Loading

As to questions about intelligence matters, Turnbull would only say he'd adopt "my normal circumspection and discretion".

Advertisement

But Trump's presidency is anything but normal.

Illustration: John Shakespeare

Ever since the US intelligence agencies raised concern in January about Russian interference in the US election, and the FBI began probing possible links between Moscow and the Trump campaign, you can bet American friends and allies began wondering if their secrets would be safe.

This wasn't initially considered much of a risk - at least in Australia, I was told - nor was there grave concern about Trump's pledge to allow torture during interrogation of suspects.

But four months of Trump chaos later, the question must be asked again. Russia would certainly love to see the official trust in America's spy agencies further crumble and given Lavrov was in the room with Trump when the supposed secrets were blurted out, it seems little wonder the story leaked.

Advertisement

Australia is one of the allies who have historically passed on top secret intelligence to the US, in return gaining access to a treasure trove of US classified material.

Donald Trump smiles while meeting with Abu Dhabi's Crown Prince Sheikh Mohammed bin Zayed Al Nahyan on Monday.AP

It was a relationship founded during the Cold War, and includes Britain, Canada and New Zealand - the so-called "Five Eyes". The deal offers enormous potential benefit to Australia, with access to a far broader view of the world than it could afford to gather alone.

The US also benefits, exposing key Australian officials to American perspectives.

Malcolm Turnbull: "If we don't sell [coal] to [India], someone else will.''Daniel Munoz
Advertisement

But paradoxically, in a business that deals in secrets and deception, trust is the most valuable commodity.

And trust is exactly what Trump's antics call into doubt.

US President Donald Trump meeting with Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov in the Oval Office.Russia Foreign Ministry/AP

The White House attacked the Washington Post story "as reported" but late on Tuesday Trump defended his decision to share information, saying he wanted Moscow to do more against Islamic State.

Advertisement

It certainly sound credible that Trump would boast, "I get great intel. I have people brief me on great intel every day."

Oh, really, Mr President? Do tell.

View post on X
View post on X
Daniel FlittonDaniel Flitton is senior correspondent for The Age covering foreign affairs and politics. He is a former intelligence analyst for the Australian government and was at one-time a university lecturer specialising in international relations.Connect via X or Facebook.

From our partners

Advertisement
Advertisement