Cricket experts are criticising the green-topped MCG pitch after 20 wickets fell on the opening day of the Boxing Day Test.
The Australians were bowled out for 152 before the tea break as the English bowlers exploited a surface that allowed considerable sideways movement off the seam.
The English were then rolled for 110 in a game that is now already into its third innings and in serious doubt of making it into a third day. Australia will start day two at 0-4 in its second dig - night watchman Scott Boland on four, and Travis Head yet to face a ball.
“There will be a discussion at the end of the day’s play about the pitch and there will be articles written about the pitch whether it’s a good pitch, whether it’s a bad pitch,” cricket commentator Mark Howard said on Kayo Sports’ live Ashes coverage.
Former Australian fast bowler Brett Lee said the pitch had too much in it for the bowlers.
“Well, I use the word sporty, and I’ve often said, ‘look it’s a batsmen’s game, we’re here to see batsman score runs’, but I think it’s a bit too sporty in my opinion,” Lee said.
“I think there’s a little bit too much in it.”
Lee said the 10mm of grass on top of the pitch at the start of the day’s play presented a “furry sort-of feeling”.
“I rubbed my hand on the side of the wicket this morning, and you can actually feel the grass lift up,” he said.
Howard said the batters were the first to notice the unusual conditions this morning.
“There were raised eyebrows as the majority of batters from both sides looked at the pitch,” he said.
Australian women’s wicketkeeper Alyssa Healy and the partner of fast bowler Mitchell Starc said she liked the surface.
“I personally like it,” she said. “I love seeing fast bowlers charge in, get something out of the surface, give themselves some confidence as well l like that.
“And it’s always the way when wickets fall too quickly that we speak about the wicket.
“It’s a hot topic of conversation in our household, it’s never how good the bowling is, it’s always about how bad the batting is when we talk about the wicket.”