The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement

This was published 8 months ago

Curnow declares he is staying at Blues; Docherty bows out as Hawks win comfortably

Roy Ward and Peter Ryan
Updated ,first published
Loading
Pinned post from 10.20pm on Jul 24, 2025
Go to latest

Day makes return but Hawks unconvincing despite win over Blues

By

Hawthorn have introduced the most vital card to their premiership pack, Will Day, at the right time of the season only to sub out last year’s finals star, Jai Newcombe, after he passed a fitness test before the game. Hawks coach Sam Mitchell said the midfielder would be fine to play Adelaide next week.

It was that sort of night for the Hawks, who comfortably won a flat encounter by 24 points in a game that carried as much tension as a morning cup of tea on a beach holiday.

Hawthorn’s Calsher Dear takes a spectacular mark over Carlton’s Harry O’Farrell.AFL Photos via Getty Images

Day, the club’s best player, was the final, and most important cog, to be re-introduced to the fray after being sidelined with a navicular injury since round three.

His return followed last week’s reappearance of key forward Mitch Lewis, just one round after the hugely talented Calsher Dear found form against Fremantle in his second game for the season.

The win over Carlton was the first time the three players had played together.

The match was a perfect tune-up as the disjointed and dispirited Blues aren’t capable of providing the sort of resistance the Hawks can expect if they make it to September for a second successive season.

At least the Blues can take one small win from the night as Charlie Curnow declared he would be staying at the club after reports he had explored a possible trade.

Day received a cheer when he won his first touch in the opening quarter as you’d expect for a player who is so important to the Hawks, who have won 17 of the 21 matches he has played since the start of 2024.

Carlton’s Oliver Hollands and Hawthorn’s Will Day (centre) scuffle.Getty Images

He is skilful and tough with his tackling a feature early.

Dear is a future star, his spectacular mark on the quarter time siren a contender for mark of the year. He was exciting in the air, taking three memorable grabs in the first half and then a huge grab in the final quarter. He is a lock for one of the key forward posts.

Lewis was impressive too, kicking his first goal since round 18 last season after taking a strong grab early in the game.

He is mobile and demands the ball and will be challenging Mabior Chol for a key forward post in the finals. Jack Gunston kept winding back the clock in an outstanding season, and the trio of key forwards combined for seven goals.

Despite all that happening, the Hawks were not convincing. Once they opened up a five-goal margin in the first quarter they seemed content to turn the match into a holding pattern.

It was disappointing as there was an opportunity to build percentage in a season where it actually matters, as the Hawks were 40 points up early in the match.

They won by just four goals when the lead seemed to be more than 10 goals for most of the match.

The Blues may have wanted to put on a show for veteran Sam Docherty’s retirement and Jacob Weitering’s 200th match, but they were incapable.

Carlton’s Sam Docherty is chaired off the ground after his final game.Getty Images

The Blues dominated contested ball early but were torched on the outside of the contest with Hawthorn running them ragged.

They threw Tom DeKoning forward alongside Harry McKay while Curnow roamed far and wide, but it didn’t work.

Tom Barrass, Jack Scrimshaw and James Sicily thrashed them taking intercept mark after intercept mark before distributing the ball to any of their runners Jarman Impey, Karl Amon and Massimo D’Ambrosio.

It was Barrass and Sicily’s best games for the season. At half-time McKay had one disposal, Jesse Motlop just two and DeKoning five.

But Carlton’s midfield was competing, young defender Harry O’Farrell was having a serious dip and Will White showed enthusiasm when he kicked the first of his two goals.

The sting seemed to leave the game until Docherty provided a nice moment when he kicked a goal in the third quarter and took a bow in front of an appreciative crowd.

He played well giving his all as only he can, but his teammates weren’t quite on the same page with Curnow having just one touch in the second half, his mind seemingly on sun and surf. He finished the game on the bench.

But the main interest lies in Hawks who are hanging in the top eight and hoping for a lift in performance.

They will hope Newcombe’s injury is minor and that Day, Lewis and Dear can recover and help the team build momentum into finals.

Latest Posts

That’s all we have for you tonight

By

That’s all we have for you tonight.

Thanks for following along this evening and please join us again tomorrow night for our Friday footy blog.

Bye for now.

‘I’m playing at Carlton next year’: Curnow stands and delivers

By

Carlton star Charlie Curnow has declared he is not going anywhere as he moved to shut down the prospect of being traded to Gold Coast, Sydney or Geelong when the Blues’ miserable season finally ends.

He stood tall in front of reporters post-game and said the words most Blues fans wanted to hear after the club lost its 12th match for the season.

Charlie Curnow of the Blues is congratulated by Ashton Moir after kicking a goal.Getty Images

“I obviously want to be here … I’m playing at Carlton next year boys, there you go, done,” Curnow said.“Nothing is happening. So [I will] pretty much put in my time into playing footy at this club next year and the future years.”

‘Sometimes, not always’ the theme for the Blues

By

Blues coach Michael Voss laments that his side’s whole season could be surmised as “sometimes, not always”.

The season has been one to forget and Voss said he knows his side has to change that starting with their last few games of this season.

Blues coach Michael Voss walks off the ground.Getty Images

“That’s been most of our season. We’ve been sometimes, not always. We’ve had patches when we are great and patches where we have let ourselves down and that’s almost been the story of our season.

“That’s the gap we’ve got to bridge.”

Voss said his players had to take all they could from their remaining matches, especially when they face finals-bound teams.

“There is always something to play for and there is no protect or save here, we are running right up to the line,” Voss said.

Advertisement

Mitchell says Newcombe will be fine for Crows clash

By

Hawks coach Sam Mitchell asked for permission before subbing Jai Newcombe out of tonight’s game and he said the star midfielder would be fine to face Adelaide in a crucial game next Friday night.

Newcombe passed a fitness test before tonight’s match and he was rested for the second half.

Jai Newcombe of the Hawks warms up.Getty Images

“I spoke to him on the phone and said I was thinking of subbing him off and he said, ‘That might not be a bad idea’,” Mitchell said with a laugh.

“He was cramping in his hips or something, but he was fine and could have kept playing.

Doherty was carried off by his idol

By

Sam Docherty revealed having Kade Simpson carry him off was a very touching moment.

“It’s something I’ll take with me for a long time, was Simmo chairing me off at the end, that was pretty special,” Doherty told Fox Footy.

Sam Docherty of the Blues is chaired from the field after his final game by Patrick Cripps of the Blues (left) and Kade Simpson.AFL Photos via Getty Images

“Patrick Cripps told him he had to do it and Sam Mitchell took a bag from him and pushed him over.

“He helped me when I was a kid, he was my idol as a player and I loved my time playing with him. I tried to follow what he taught me to do, it’s a very special moment.”

Curnow declares he will be back with the Blues next season

By

Carlton star Charlie Curnow has moved to end speculation he wants to leave the Blues telling reporters post game he will definitely continue his career at Ikon Park.

“I’ll be playing at Carlton next year boys,” Curnow said.

Charlie Curnow of the Blues is congratulated by teammates.Getty Images

He admitted the season had been frustrating but said “things can turn quickly” and he was determined to push through the adversity.

MORE TO COME

Advertisement

‘I’ve got a little left in the legs’: Day

By

Will Day spoke to Fox Footy post game.

On his return from injury:

It was awesome to be out there, it was a bloody slog but to be back out there, with Mitch Lewis on the MCG, it was pretty special.

Did helping the coaches out aid in your return to the game?

I just wanted to stay as involved as I could and being a leader of the club, I wanted to have an influence on the group.

Full-time stats

By
Pinned post from 10.20pm on Jul 24, 2025

Day makes return but Hawks unconvincing despite win over Blues

By

Hawthorn have introduced the most vital card to their premiership pack, Will Day, at the right time of the season only to sub out last year’s finals star, Jai Newcombe, after he passed a fitness test before the game. Hawks coach Sam Mitchell said the midfielder would be fine to play Adelaide next week.

It was that sort of night for the Hawks, who comfortably won a flat encounter by 24 points in a game that carried as much tension as a morning cup of tea on a beach holiday.

Hawthorn’s Calsher Dear takes a spectacular mark over Carlton’s Harry O’Farrell.AFL Photos via Getty Images

Day, the club’s best player, was the final, and most important cog, to be re-introduced to the fray after being sidelined with a navicular injury since round three.

His return followed last week’s reappearance of key forward Mitch Lewis, just one round after the hugely talented Calsher Dear found form against Fremantle in his second game for the season.

The win over Carlton was the first time the three players had played together.

The match was a perfect tune-up as the disjointed and dispirited Blues aren’t capable of providing the sort of resistance the Hawks can expect if they make it to September for a second successive season.

At least the Blues can take one small win from the night as Charlie Curnow declared he would be staying at the club after reports he had explored a possible trade.

Day received a cheer when he won his first touch in the opening quarter as you’d expect for a player who is so important to the Hawks, who have won 17 of the 21 matches he has played since the start of 2024.

Carlton’s Oliver Hollands and Hawthorn’s Will Day (centre) scuffle.Getty Images

He is skilful and tough with his tackling a feature early.

Dear is a future star, his spectacular mark on the quarter time siren a contender for mark of the year. He was exciting in the air, taking three memorable grabs in the first half and then a huge grab in the final quarter. He is a lock for one of the key forward posts.

Lewis was impressive too, kicking his first goal since round 18 last season after taking a strong grab early in the game.

He is mobile and demands the ball and will be challenging Mabior Chol for a key forward post in the finals. Jack Gunston kept winding back the clock in an outstanding season, and the trio of key forwards combined for seven goals.

Despite all that happening, the Hawks were not convincing. Once they opened up a five-goal margin in the first quarter they seemed content to turn the match into a holding pattern.

It was disappointing as there was an opportunity to build percentage in a season where it actually matters, as the Hawks were 40 points up early in the match.

They won by just four goals when the lead seemed to be more than 10 goals for most of the match.

The Blues may have wanted to put on a show for veteran Sam Docherty’s retirement and Jacob Weitering’s 200th match, but they were incapable.

Carlton’s Sam Docherty is chaired off the ground after his final game.Getty Images

The Blues dominated contested ball early but were torched on the outside of the contest with Hawthorn running them ragged.

They threw Tom DeKoning forward alongside Harry McKay while Curnow roamed far and wide, but it didn’t work.

Tom Barrass, Jack Scrimshaw and James Sicily thrashed them taking intercept mark after intercept mark before distributing the ball to any of their runners Jarman Impey, Karl Amon and Massimo D’Ambrosio.

It was Barrass and Sicily’s best games for the season. At half-time McKay had one disposal, Jesse Motlop just two and DeKoning five.

But Carlton’s midfield was competing, young defender Harry O’Farrell was having a serious dip and Will White showed enthusiasm when he kicked the first of his two goals.

The sting seemed to leave the game until Docherty provided a nice moment when he kicked a goal in the third quarter and took a bow in front of an appreciative crowd.

He played well giving his all as only he can, but his teammates weren’t quite on the same page with Curnow having just one touch in the second half, his mind seemingly on sun and surf. He finished the game on the bench.

But the main interest lies in Hawks who are hanging in the top eight and hoping for a lift in performance.

They will hope Newcombe’s injury is minor and that Day, Lewis and Dear can recover and help the team build momentum into finals.

Advertisement

Simpson chairs off Docherty

By

Blues great turned Hawks assistant coach Kade Simpson teamed with Patrick Cripps to chair Sam Docherty off the ground.

Jacob Weitering was also carried off in his 200th game.

Docherty then took a moment to run over to the Carlton chair squad to thank them for their support.

Now he is walking off the ground.

What a farewell.

Sam Docherty of the Blues bows to the crowd after kicking a goal.AFL Photos via Getty Images
Advertisement