The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement

This was published 7 months ago

McRae keeps faith in Pies despite Crows loss as debate rages over non-free kick in dying moments

Roy Ward, Jon Pierik, Danny Russell, Scott Spits and Steve Barrett
Updated ,first published
Loading
Pinned post from 10.28pm on Aug 16, 2025
Go to latest

Crows come up clutch to score Pies win after 3318 days

By Steve Barrett

Adelaide hung on by the tips of their fingernails but, at long last, shook their Magpie monkey.

The nine-year Collingwood curse is dead. After 3318 long days, Adelaide busted one of the AFL’s longest spells, in front of 54,283 fans - the biggest ever AFL crowd at Adelaide Oval - beating Collingwood for the first time since 16 July 2016.

Izak Rankine celebrates a goal.Getty Images

When the Crows last defeated the Magpies - some 3318 days ago - Barack Obama was still US president, Malcolm Turnbull had been sworn in as Australian Prime Minister and Scott Pendlebury was racking up touch after touch.

Well, some things haven’t changed.

More importantly, Saturday night’s pulsating three-point triumph all but sealed the Crows’ first minor premiership since 2017 - the last time they made the top eight.

Adelaide had to work overtime for this one, particularly their backline which was inundated by one Collingwood entry after another.

The Pies amassed a whopping 71-39 advantage in inside-50s but just couldn’t land the killer blow.

The brilliant Nick Daicos’s goal on the burst in the 27th minute of the fourth quarter was the game’s final score, Collingwood attacking hard to the finish line.

The Magpies had it all on their terms early, marching to a 25-point quarter-time cushion after 30 minutes of the footy almost exclusively living inside their forward half.

But no deficit is beyond Adelaide’s potent reach and they turned the tables emphatically with a 5.1 to 0.1 second term, allowing them to pinch a five-point half-time lead.

The heavens opened in the third stanza which descended into a defensive-dominated sodden slog, the Crows spending most of it on the ropes but repeatedly warding off glancing Collingwood blows.

Another goal drought followed in the fourth, finally busted by James Peatling in the 18th minute, Adelaide’s single-figure lead seemingly worth plenty more.

Riley Thilthorpe, largely subdued by ex-Crow Billy Frampton, took a huge clutch mark on his guy and converted to restore Adelaide’s nine-point lead.

If this was a September dress rehearsal between the cagey 2023 champions and the upstart challengers, the sequel looms as a beauty.

Latest Posts

That’s all for tonight

By

That’s all we have for you tonight.

Thanks so much for joining us throughout the day and into tonight.

Please keep visiting our sports webpages for more AFL coverage tomorrow and throughout the week.

Bye for now.

‘That stuff will stack up’: McRae on Pies

By Steve Barrett

The Magpies are on course for wins, of that coach Craig McRae is sure despite their close loss to Adelaide on Saturday night.

“We didn’t get the four points, but internally, we know we’re headed in the right direction,” Magpies coach Craig McRae said.

Jordan De Goey of the Magpies is chased by Wayne Milera of the Crows.AFL Photos via Getty Images

“You put the (Collingwood) jumper on this week and there’s a lot more pride in the way we went about it.

“There’s an internal belief that this game was there for us to win.

McRae still believes in Magpies despite losing run

By Roy Ward

Collingwood coach Craig McRae had an interesting take on his side’s dominance on inside 50s but failure to turn them into goals.

The Magpies had 71-37 inside 50s but much of that dominance came in the first term before the rain set in as the team fell to a fifth loss in six games.

Magpies coach Craig McRae.AFL Photos via Getty Images

McRae said the “high density” of the Crows defence, the rain plus the high pressure being applied by both sides made clean possessions hard to come by.

“The reality of that kind of game is, as Leigh Matthews used to say, it will be hard for us to score so make it impossible for them,” McRae said.

Advertisement

Howe could return, Hill uncertain

By Roy Ward

The Magpies hope to get Jeremy Howe back for the final round but star forward Bobby Hill’s return remains uncertain although he is back training.

Magpies coach Craig McRae said Howe would bring a lot of strength to the team’s defence once he comes out of the concussion protocols.

Magpies defender Jeremy Howe warms up before facing the Hawks.Getty Images

“Howey should be available next week and out of the protocols and Bobby is getting better every day but I’m not sure if he will be available next week,” McRae said.

“But it was pleasing having him back this week training hard for us. We might strengthen up next week if we get Howey back.”

McRae also said the team’s AFL and VFL sides both haven’t reported any injuries from this weekend.

Daicos says midfield must lift

By

Magpies star Nick Daicos has put the heat on his team’s midfield to improve how they are delivering the ball to the forwards.

The Magpies forward line continues to struggle and they’ve lost five of their last six games.

Nick Daicos of the Magpies tries to get through Jordan Dawson and Wayne Milera of the Crows.Getty Images

“It’s probably on the midfield,” Daicos told Fox Footy.

“I think the forwards set up well. It’s on us [the midfield] to tidy up a few things.

“If we can get our forward line out in space, we will be a better team.”

‘We haven’t achieved anything yet’: Nicks

By

Matthew Nicks has revealed what premiership-winning veteran Alex Neal-Bullen told the group as they entered the final weeks of the season.

“A very experienced man told me that we haven’t achieved anything yet,” Nicks told Fox Footy.

“His name is Alex Neal-Bullen and when you bring players like him into your football club and can sit down and share experiences they’ve had. Murray Davis is another one.

“We haven’t achieved anything yet. We are not here to finish top with one round to go, we are here to have a real crack.”

Alex Neal-Bullen of the Crows celebrates a goal.AFL Photos
Advertisement

‘As long as we won by a kick’: Nicks on inside 50s differential

By Roy Ward

Crows coach Matthew Nicks had a cracking line when asked what would have thought if he was told pre-game that Collingwood would win inside 50s 71-37.

“I wouldn’t have cared as long as we won by a kick,” Nicks told Fox Footy.

Darcy Fogarty of the Crows celebrates their win.AFL Photos via Getty Images

“We will go back and review it. I thought they played better than we did as far as their game goes, we didn’t get our best game at all.

“The last couple of weeks we have been a little bit off but still been able to get the job done.

Pinned post from 10.28pm on Aug 16, 2025

Crows come up clutch to score Pies win after 3318 days

By Steve Barrett

Adelaide hung on by the tips of their fingernails but, at long last, shook their Magpie monkey.

The nine-year Collingwood curse is dead. After 3318 long days, Adelaide busted one of the AFL’s longest spells, in front of 54,283 fans - the biggest ever AFL crowd at Adelaide Oval - beating Collingwood for the first time since 16 July 2016.

Izak Rankine celebrates a goal.Getty Images

When the Crows last defeated the Magpies - some 3318 days ago - Barack Obama was still US president, Malcolm Turnbull had been sworn in as Australian Prime Minister and Scott Pendlebury was racking up touch after touch.

Well, some things haven’t changed.

More importantly, Saturday night’s pulsating three-point triumph all but sealed the Crows’ first minor premiership since 2017 - the last time they made the top eight.

Adelaide had to work overtime for this one, particularly their backline which was inundated by one Collingwood entry after another.

The Pies amassed a whopping 71-39 advantage in inside-50s but just couldn’t land the killer blow.

The brilliant Nick Daicos’s goal on the burst in the 27th minute of the fourth quarter was the game’s final score, Collingwood attacking hard to the finish line.

The Magpies had it all on their terms early, marching to a 25-point quarter-time cushion after 30 minutes of the footy almost exclusively living inside their forward half.

But no deficit is beyond Adelaide’s potent reach and they turned the tables emphatically with a 5.1 to 0.1 second term, allowing them to pinch a five-point half-time lead.

The heavens opened in the third stanza which descended into a defensive-dominated sodden slog, the Crows spending most of it on the ropes but repeatedly warding off glancing Collingwood blows.

Another goal drought followed in the fourth, finally busted by James Peatling in the 18th minute, Adelaide’s single-figure lead seemingly worth plenty more.

Riley Thilthorpe, largely subdued by ex-Crow Billy Frampton, took a huge clutch mark on his guy and converted to restore Adelaide’s nine-point lead.

If this was a September dress rehearsal between the cagey 2023 champions and the upstart challengers, the sequel looms as a beauty.

Did Thilthorpe kick the ball away late?

By Roy Ward

Garry Lyon has called it “the worst non-free kick of the season” but I can’t agree with him.

With the ball out of bounds in the final minutes and rolling between two boundary umpires, Riley Thilthorpe appeared to kick the ball away.

Riley Thilthorpe was not penalised for kicking the ball away in the dying moments of the Adelaide-Collingwood clash.Fox Footy

But a second angle showed that the ball he kicked rolled towards the other, further away boundary umpire.

It could have been a free kick, but it was better to leave it and let the on field play decide the play - at least in my view.

I think the two clear throw passes that were missed in open play were far more troubling.

Advertisement

How the Crows can finish on top

By

To finish on top of the ladder, the Crows either need Geelong to lose to Sydney on Sunday or they need to win their final round clash with North Melbourne next weekend.

The Magpies fall further back to the field when it comes to trying to secure one of the remaining top four spots.

“We are very confident, we know our roles and trust each other to get it done,” Riley Thilthorpe told Fox Footy.

James Peatling of the Crows celebrates a goal.AFL Photos via Getty Images
Advertisement