The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement

This was published 7 months ago

Lions take third spot after winning heavyweight bout; Dog of a day for flat Beveridge

Scott Spits, Peter Ryan, Marc McGowan and Vince Rugari
Updated ,first published
Loading
Pinned post from 10.08pm on Aug 24, 2025
Go to latest

ANALYSIS: Late controversy but ‘Lions deserved the win’

By

The Brisbane Lions made hard work of it, but the reigning premiers are back in their fifth qualifying final in seven seasons after defeating a gallant Hawks by 10 points in a classic encounter at the Gabba.

The win puts them into a qualifying final against Geelong, who they have beaten in their past three encounters. Hawthorn have to wait to see whether Gold Coast beat Essendon and the margin before knowing if they finish seventh or eighth to play the Giants or Fremantle away in an elimination final.

The Lions were the better team with their midfield dominating but were unable to capitalise on their territory advantage kicking 0.8 in the first quarter and then 2.9 in the third quarter.

It took a dubious umpiring decision against Hawthorn for insufficient intent to settle the contest with just two points separating the two teams with six minutes left.

View post on X

Bruce Reville goaled from the free kick which should be debated as it is not what the rule intends and the Lions immediately kicked another goal through Cameron Rayner from a centre clearance and the match was over.

Such a call was disappointing however the Lions deserved the win.

They won the inside 50 count and their three best midfielders Hugh McCluggage, Josh Dunkley and Will Ashcroft were better than the Hawks who relied on bounce from half back to score.

Their guns were Amon and Jarman Impey who used the ball bravely to ensure the Hawks kept turning up and hanging in the contest. But they could not get their noses back in front.

Jack Ginnivan and Mabior Chol were the Hawks best forwards while Kai Lohmann and Rayner turned the match for the Lions.

The Lions would have been ruing their inaccuracy if they had lost but it was not completely unexpected as their accuracy has been an issue on more than one occasion during Chris Fagan’s reign as coach.

It has been a tough year for the purists but the match at the Gabba reclaimed some ground with a classic between the Brisbane Lions and Hawthorn.

Dayne Zorko, who played his 300th game, said the team were saying at quarter time the goalkicking could not get any worse (of course it did in the third quarter).

“The message [at quarter-time] was ‘don’t get frustrated and move on’,” Charlie Cameron told Channel 7.

The top six is set: Adelaide vs Collingwood, Geelong vs Brisbane Lions, GWS Giants vs either Hawthorn or Gold Coast, Fremantle vs either Hawthorn or Gold Coast. Four opening finals in four states and a guaranteed final in Queensland in either second or third week of finals.

Latest Posts

Good night and thanks

By Scott Spits

It’s been a bumper day of AFL action. Tonight’s Brisbane-Hawthorn clash was worthy of a final, which is fitting as while this year’s top eight is not quite set, the top six is set in stone. Can Essendon pull off a miracle on Wednesday by defeating Gold Coast to deny the Suns a finals spot? Highly unlikely but we’ll be watching on.

Good night.

Toby Greene stars as Giants nab home final

By Vince Rugari

Sometimes, it takes a moment of brilliance to win a match. Sometimes, to save a match. Sometimes, it takes two.

With the game – and a home final – on the line late in Sunday’s clash against St Kilda, the Giants needed something from someone to stave off the distinctly real possibility of a late raid from the visitors.

Enter Toby Greene, who did what can only be described as Toby Greene things, hauling in not one, but a pair of spectacular contested marks inside the final two minutes of their pulsating 11-point win at Engie Stadium, shaving crucial seconds off the clock while also snapping the Saints’ momentum.

“When you’ve got to go, you’ve just got to go,” Greene said after the match. “Sometimes you hang on to them, sometimes you don’t.”

The first was in Greater Western Sydney’s forward pocket, as they held a four-point lead. He could have won the match for them, then and there, with his set shot from a difficult angle. Though he missed, he had the presence of mind to flood the corridor ahead of St Kilda’s kick-in – and there he was, chopping off the Saints’ long bomb into the centre square with another crucial mark, almost chopping off the head of teammate Lachie Whitfield in the process.

Vote: Which player is your pick?

By
Advertisement

Dog of a day for flat Bevo

By Marc McGowan

Western Bulldogs coach Luke Beveridge has conceded his side will miss finals after failing against a top-eight rival again in a 15-point final-round defeat to Fremantle.

The Bulldogs led the Dockers by 16 points early in Sunday’s contest at Marvel Stadium before Fremantle’s seven-goal-to-none, second-quarter avalanche propelled them to a victory that sealed their first finals berth since 2022.

Beveridge’s Dogs, who won only twice in 10 matches against top-eight opponents this year, need an injury-ravaged Essendon to cause a major boilover on the Gold Coast on Wednesday night against the Suns to qualify for September.

Barring that highly unlikely scenario, the Bulldogs will finish ninth for the second time in three seasons despite winning 14 games in 2025.

A tough pill to swallow: Desperate disappointment for the Western Bulldogs.Getty Images

The HUGE umpiring decision late in the game

By
The controversial umpiring decision - a free kick paid against Hawthorn’s Karl Amon for insufficient intent deep into the last quarter.Fox Footy

Congrats Zorko on 300 matches

By
View post on X
Advertisement

Lions ‘too good tonight’, says Hawk

By Peter Ryan

Lloyd Meek in the Hawthorn rooms: ”Really tough, it is hard at this end of the year. Everyone knows how important those games are and we gave it our all and Brisbane were too good tonight. So hopefully get to play them again at some point and a week off, reset, take plenty of positives out of it but gutted at this point.”

The finishing positions (so far)

By

NOTE: Gold Coast (in ninth spot) have the chance to grab a finals spot when they play Essendon on Wednesday. The Suns must win.

Vote: Your thoughts

By
Advertisement
Pinned post from 10.08pm on Aug 24, 2025

ANALYSIS: Late controversy but ‘Lions deserved the win’

By

The Brisbane Lions made hard work of it, but the reigning premiers are back in their fifth qualifying final in seven seasons after defeating a gallant Hawks by 10 points in a classic encounter at the Gabba.

The win puts them into a qualifying final against Geelong, who they have beaten in their past three encounters. Hawthorn have to wait to see whether Gold Coast beat Essendon and the margin before knowing if they finish seventh or eighth to play the Giants or Fremantle away in an elimination final.

The Lions were the better team with their midfield dominating but were unable to capitalise on their territory advantage kicking 0.8 in the first quarter and then 2.9 in the third quarter.

It took a dubious umpiring decision against Hawthorn for insufficient intent to settle the contest with just two points separating the two teams with six minutes left.

View post on X

Bruce Reville goaled from the free kick which should be debated as it is not what the rule intends and the Lions immediately kicked another goal through Cameron Rayner from a centre clearance and the match was over.

Such a call was disappointing however the Lions deserved the win.

They won the inside 50 count and their three best midfielders Hugh McCluggage, Josh Dunkley and Will Ashcroft were better than the Hawks who relied on bounce from half back to score.

Their guns were Amon and Jarman Impey who used the ball bravely to ensure the Hawks kept turning up and hanging in the contest. But they could not get their noses back in front.

Jack Ginnivan and Mabior Chol were the Hawks best forwards while Kai Lohmann and Rayner turned the match for the Lions.

The Lions would have been ruing their inaccuracy if they had lost but it was not completely unexpected as their accuracy has been an issue on more than one occasion during Chris Fagan’s reign as coach.

It has been a tough year for the purists but the match at the Gabba reclaimed some ground with a classic between the Brisbane Lions and Hawthorn.

Dayne Zorko, who played his 300th game, said the team were saying at quarter time the goalkicking could not get any worse (of course it did in the third quarter).

“The message [at quarter-time] was ‘don’t get frustrated and move on’,” Charlie Cameron told Channel 7.

The top six is set: Adelaide vs Collingwood, Geelong vs Brisbane Lions, GWS Giants vs either Hawthorn or Gold Coast, Fremantle vs either Hawthorn or Gold Coast. Four opening finals in four states and a guaranteed final in Queensland in either second or third week of finals.

Advertisement