The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement

This was published 1 year ago

Cats stunned by St Kilda’s ‘Harlem Globetrotters’; Houston’s heavy bump sparks tempers in Showdown

Roy Ward, Danny Russell, Andrew Stafford, Steve Barrett and Hannah Hammoud
Updated ,first published
Loading
Pinned post from 10.33pm on Aug 17, 2024
Go to latest

KEY POINTS: Saints stun Cats to throw top-four hopes into doubt

By Andrew Stafford

ST KILDA 16.11 (107) d GEELONG 14.5 (89)

Mitch Owens of the Saints attempts to mark the ball.Getty Images

KEY POINTS

CATS HAD IT ALL TO PLAY FOR
Geelong had plenty to play for against the Saints — even more so, after Collingwood edged the Brisbane Lions at the MCG. A win at Marvel would have sewn up yet another top four finish and given them an unlikely shot at the title in this most unlikely of years. At half-time, this game was firmly in their grasp. What the hell happened? That’s something coach Chris Scott and his crew will ponder during the week, but they can’t afford to dwell on it for long. They’ve got the Eagles next week at home, a game that on paper shouldn’t trouble them. And they’ll have to give credit to St Kilda for their incredible second half. But this game still showed up their vulnerabilities, particularly if you can quieten Jeremy Cameron, as Josh Battle did heroically, notwithstanding two late goals from the champion. Their defence was pulled apart in the second half, conceding 27 shots at goal.

Darcy Wilson.Getty Images

WILSON A STAR ON THE RISE
While a first-rounder, Darcy Wilson wasn’t a headline act at last year’s national draft. The Saints picked him up at No. 18. Well, they have got themselves a star. Wilson has played all 22 games this year, and his performance against Geelong was absolutely sublime. He ran, and he ran; he was elusive, he kicked 2.3 and should have had four, he can use the ball on both sides of his body, and he looks like he’d been playing forever. When St Kilda looked like submitting meekly after a half, it was Wilson who set them alight, and for a side that can be dour, his dare, inventiveness and class stood out. Indeed, it appeared to be contagious. St Kilda hasn’t played a better quarter all year than their third at Marvel. Their season is done, they still have a long way to go, but they have got something to work with, and Wilson is the kind of talent they can build around.

NOTHING IS CERTAIN
In a season of endless permutations, who’d be a tipster? This game was bonkers, characterised by a massive swing in momentum. But hasn’t that been the story of season 2024? Perhaps every coach in the competition will be thinking over the summer about how to stop sides when they throw caution to the wind and go for broke. And of all the bonkers wins this year, this had to be one of the most unexpected, given the Saints’ lacklustre performance to half-time. Apparently, they got a classic Ross Lyon bake at half-time — and they came out playing a scintillating brand of football that would likely have beaten anyone on the day. There will doubtless be some frustration from Saints fans: where has this been? But there’ll be frustration from Cats fans, too, that they didn’t put this game away. Will the real premiership favourite please stand up?

KEY STATS

Latest Posts

That’s all for tonight

By

Thanks for joining us today everyone.

Have a lovely evening and please join us again in the afternoon for our AFL Sunday blog.

Bye for now.

Fagan insists Lions remain optimistic after tough loss

By

Brisbane coach Chris Fagan insists he will remain optimistic in the wake of the Lions blowing a golden opportunity to secure a top-four AFL finish by losing to Collingwood by a point.

The Lions led all game at the MCG on Saturday, until Beau McCreery snapped the match-winner at the 29-minute mark of the final quarter.

Lions coach Chris Fagan.Getty Images

Brisbane were their own worst enemies, missing a glut of gettable shots, particularly during the third quarter, to only lead by 14 points at the final change.

The Lions appeared home when Charlie Cameron’s clever snap put them 17 points up at the 20-minute mark of the final quarter.

Wilson will play every game: Lyon

By

St Kilda coach Ross Lyon believes first-year midfielder Darcy Wilson had a “breakout game” with a starring role in tonight’s win over Geelong at Marvel Stadium.

Wilson finished with 25 disposals and two goals while playing a pivotal role in the club’s second-half smashing of the Cats.

“Robert Harvey works closely with him. He’s had a few good games but this is probably his first breakout game,” Lyon said.

“He’s part of what we’re doing with the young players, he’ll play every game this year as a first-round pick as Mattaes [Phillipou] did last year, he didn’t play tonight because he was sick.

“With what they throw at you tactically, Wilson was a part of that. He runs so well.”

Advertisement

‘It was the Harlem Globetrotters at one stage’: Scott stunned in defeat

By

Cats coach Chris Scott spoke to the media post game.

Chris, how do you assess that, especially that second half fade out, I guess?

Well, it’s obviously disappointing. We can sit here and sort of state the obvious. I wouldn’t describe it as a fade-out so much. It didn’t look like we were in the game and dropping out as the quarter...as the half went on. They just blew us out of the water early and had the momentum. It was really hard for us to stop it. They played some scintillating footy. It was kind of Harlem Globetrotters at one stage and it was unusual because the first half was clearly on our terms. We know they can do that. They are Marvel specialists, they play here a lot. This is our first game here. That’s not an excuse. Our first half is how we play and the second half looked completely different. It was some pretty good footy. We were throwing things around left, right and centre but we just kept getting beaten in contests, which is very hard to manage from off the field.

Jack Sinclair of the Saints tackles Tom Stewart of the Cats.Getty Images

Anything in terms of out of character or purely down to St Kilda getting you and that’s all?

Cats turn eyes to West Coast

By

Cats midfielder Tom Atkins spoke to Seven post game.

Tom, obviously a tough loss. A tale of two second halves. What was said at half-time?

Nothing in particular. I thought we started the game really well. It was more a conversation of scores reset and let’s go again. It’s disappointing we weren’t able to do that. We just chased bum, I guess, we chased bum for a quarter, quarter-and-a-half and then we didn’t have the legs to come back in the end. That’s what happens when you don’t make early enough defensive decisions at Marvel. The ball goes end to end pretty quick.

What was Chris’s message after the game?

He said we have to move forward, can’t dwell on this, we haven’t got the top four sewn up. That’s the focus. Take 12 hours to mull over the game but certainly Monday, come in ready to beat West Coast next week.

KEY POINTS: Power wins Showdown as Rankine knocked out by Houston

By Steve Barrett

PORT ADELAIDE 11.14 (80) d ADELAIDE 8.10 (58)

Izak Rankine of the Crows is knocked out after a collision with Dan Houston of the Power.Getty Images

KEY POINTS

HOUSTON ROCKS RANKINE
Dan Houston may have played his last game in Port Adelaide colours after ending Izak Rankine’s night – and his season – with a massive bump which caused tempers in Saturday night’s ill-tempered Showdown to explode. Every Adelaide player made a beeline for Houston, who is contracted until at Alberton 2027 but strongly linked to a return to his home state Victoria, in the third quarter after his huge shirtfront forced Rankine to be stretchered off Adelaide Oval.

Matt Crouch took a swing at Travis Boak in the ensuing melee which involved all players from both teams in arguably the most acrimonious Showdown since the brutal 2008 derby, famous for Nathan Bassett being concussed by Matt Thomas, Luke Jericho getting cleaned up by Dean Brogan and Bernie Vince being bumped by Daniel Motlop.

Advertisement
Pinned post from 10.33pm on Aug 17, 2024

KEY POINTS: Saints stun Cats to throw top-four hopes into doubt

By Andrew Stafford

ST KILDA 16.11 (107) d GEELONG 14.5 (89)

Mitch Owens of the Saints attempts to mark the ball.Getty Images

KEY POINTS

CATS HAD IT ALL TO PLAY FOR
Geelong had plenty to play for against the Saints — even more so, after Collingwood edged the Brisbane Lions at the MCG. A win at Marvel would have sewn up yet another top four finish and given them an unlikely shot at the title in this most unlikely of years. At half-time, this game was firmly in their grasp. What the hell happened? That’s something coach Chris Scott and his crew will ponder during the week, but they can’t afford to dwell on it for long. They’ve got the Eagles next week at home, a game that on paper shouldn’t trouble them. And they’ll have to give credit to St Kilda for their incredible second half. But this game still showed up their vulnerabilities, particularly if you can quieten Jeremy Cameron, as Josh Battle did heroically, notwithstanding two late goals from the champion. Their defence was pulled apart in the second half, conceding 27 shots at goal.

Darcy Wilson.Getty Images

WILSON A STAR ON THE RISE
While a first-rounder, Darcy Wilson wasn’t a headline act at last year’s national draft. The Saints picked him up at No. 18. Well, they have got themselves a star. Wilson has played all 22 games this year, and his performance against Geelong was absolutely sublime. He ran, and he ran; he was elusive, he kicked 2.3 and should have had four, he can use the ball on both sides of his body, and he looks like he’d been playing forever. When St Kilda looked like submitting meekly after a half, it was Wilson who set them alight, and for a side that can be dour, his dare, inventiveness and class stood out. Indeed, it appeared to be contagious. St Kilda hasn’t played a better quarter all year than their third at Marvel. Their season is done, they still have a long way to go, but they have got something to work with, and Wilson is the kind of talent they can build around.

NOTHING IS CERTAIN
In a season of endless permutations, who’d be a tipster? This game was bonkers, characterised by a massive swing in momentum. But hasn’t that been the story of season 2024? Perhaps every coach in the competition will be thinking over the summer about how to stop sides when they throw caution to the wind and go for broke. And of all the bonkers wins this year, this had to be one of the most unexpected, given the Saints’ lacklustre performance to half-time. Apparently, they got a classic Ross Lyon bake at half-time — and they came out playing a scintillating brand of football that would likely have beaten anyone on the day. There will doubtless be some frustration from Saints fans: where has this been? But there’ll be frustration from Cats fans, too, that they didn’t put this game away. Will the real premiership favourite please stand up?

KEY STATS

Magpies’ home ground advantage. It’s enough to make McRae smile

By Danny Russell and Hannah Hammoud

A beaming Craig McRae made a point of praising a parochial Collingwood crowd for dragging his Magpies over the line in a stunning comeback win at the MCG – a one-point victory that remarkably keeps their finals hope alive.

The Magpies kicked the last three goals of the game to overhaul a 17-point deficit at the 20-minute mark of the last quarter and snatch an unlikely win over last year’s grand final opponent Brisbane.

Jack Crisp (R) hugs Magpies Jeremy Howe, Brayden Maynard and Will Hoskin-Elliott on the final siren.Getty Images

They did so on the back of the classy Nick Daicos and a rampant Magpie Army screaming for the black and white. What a difference a week can make – a home ground advantage, a come-from-behind win, and the team’s finals hopes alive.

Collingwood are now sitting in 10th, play a stuttering Melbourne at the MCG on Friday night and will be sweating on the teams above them to drop their guard.

“That was us sort of showing that we never give up,” an upbeat McRae said after the game.

Click here to read the story.

Full-time stats - Saints v Cats

By
Advertisement

FT: St Kilda 16.11 (107) d Geelong 14.5 (89)

By

St Kilda have shown their ability and given their fans something to enjoy before the season ends while Geelong won’t know how damaging this loss is until the end of the final round.

If they are hosting an elimination final or travelling interstate for a qualifying final, they will only have themselves to blame.

Jack Steele of the Saints competes with Gryan Miers of the Cats.Getty Images

Two late goals to Jeremy Cameron doesn’t help all that much. The Cats let this game go when they let the Saints fight back in the third term.

Advertisement