The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement

This was published 3 years ago

As it happened: Daniel Andrews, Matthew Guy go head-to-head in final days of campaign

Broede Carmody and Caroline Schelle
Updated ,first published

Today’s developments at a glance

By

And that’s where we’ll leave our live coverage for the day.

Here’s some key points from today:

  • The two leaders debated in front of undecided voters at Box Hill Town Hall
  • Labor promises to put revived State Electricity Commission in the Victorian constitution

  • Opposition Leader Matthew Guy announced if elected on Saturday, a Coalition government will redevelop Federation Square to “bring the banks of the Yarra right up to the Hoddle grid”

Thank you for tuning in, and we will be back tomorrow with all the developments ahead of the election.

Gloves stay on in genteel debate, but masterful Andrews comes out on top

By Annika Smethurst

The gloves stayed on in a genteel debate between Premier Daniel Andrews and Liberal leader Matthew Guy in Box Hill on Tuesday night.

If the 100 apparently undecided voters, chosen by Q&A Market Research, wanted a spirited clash, this wasn’t the place.

The two leaders debated at Box Hill on Tuesday evening. Ian Currie

While many political opponents are friendly away from the despatch boxes, Guy and Andrews have never been close.

But the two men shared a joke, a handshake and were united in their pledge to offer a positive and optimistic plan.

Read more of the debate analysis from Annika Smethurst here.

Debate attendees confirm election will be tight

By Sumeyya Ilanbey

The votes are in, and it confirms this year’s election will be a tight race.

Of the undecided voters who attended the debate at Box Hill Town Hall, 38 per cent said they would vote for Daniel Andrews, while 34 per cent favoured Matthew Guy.

John asks a question at the forum on Tuesday night. Ian Currie

More than a quarter of voters (28 per cent) remained undecided after the one-hour debate.

At the last People’s Forum during the 2018 election campaign that Labor won in a landslide, 49 per cent of people backed Andrews, 33 per cent fell behind Guy.

Only 18 per cent were undecided.

Advertisement

Closing addresses focus on unity, SEC and health

By Caroline Schelle

The hour-long debate between the two leaders ended with their closing addresses to appeal to the undecided voters in the audience at Box Hill, and across the state.

Opposition Leader Matthew Guy was the first to speak to the crowd, and promised he would be a premier who would unite Victorians rather than divide them.

He said there were significant problems, but he was committed to fixing the state’s healthcare system. Here’s what else he had to say:

I want to help your families get ahead again, because I know how hard cost of living is when parents are making the decisions to either put on electricity or clothe their children because they can’t do both ... But more the point what I offered to you on what I want to tell every Victorian,  the thing I want to commit to all of you doesn’t cost a cent.

It’s a change in attitude. A premier who respects you, who listens to you, who values your opinion. Who doesn’t hector, lecture, or berate you, and I commit to all of you tonight, and all to every Victorian, to be that premier.

In response, Premier Daniel Andrews said he wanted to be re-elected to bring back the SEC, to create jobs in renewable energy and to “not repeat the errors of the past”.

These greedy companies have made their money out of us. They’re now leaving, we have to replace them with something better. We also want to continue our strong partnership with our nurses and midwives. Our ambos, to recruit more of them, to value them to respect them, not to go to war with them.

We also want to make sure that kinder is free for every family, [a] $2500 saving for every child, every year. It starts on day one next year. These are just part of our positive plan and of course, delivering that budget surplus. That’s so important. Thank you for your questions. Thank you for being here. This is my positive plan. And now it’s your choice.

Leaders question each other on health and ‘divisive’ tone

By Sumeyya Ilanbey

Before the closing statement, the two leaders were allowed to ask each other one question each.

Daniel Andrews asked Matthew Guy why he “continued to run a commentary” on the health system that ignored the hard work of healthcare workers.

Guy responded: “Your government has broken the health system, you’ve had eight years, I intend to fix it.”

Guy asked Andrews why after eight years the Andrews government adopted a “divisive” tone.

Premier Daniel Andrews and Opposition Leader Matthew Guy at the people’s forum tonight.Ian Currie

Integrity and ‘locking up journalists’ raised in debate

By Caroline Schelle

The politicians were questioned about integrity and their plans to help fund the state’s anti-corruption watchdog.

Premier Daniel Andrews also spoke about denying the watchdog’s request for law changes that would see journalists go to jail for leaking or publishing draft reports.

Opposition Leader Matthew Guy said he was part of the government that formed the Independent Broad-based Anti-Corruption Commission and would commit $20 million.

Matthew Guy spoke about integrity at tonight’s debate.skynews.com.au

“All of those agencies, particularly the ombudsman and the anti-corruption commission, at the moment, saying they’re being denied the adequate funding to do their job, and they need to expand their powers,” he said.

Advertisement

Andrews and Guy trade barbs in debate

By Sumeyya Ilanbey

Premier Daniel Andrews traded barbs with Opposition Leader Matthew Guy over the Coalition’s gas-led recovery plan.

Sky News host Kieran Gilbert asked Andrews whether Labor would pull down its ads that wrongly allege the Coalition will allow fracking as part of their plan to “turbocharge gas exploration”.

Footage from the debate between the Labor and Liberal leaders in Victoria.skynews.com.au

For the first time during the debate, Andrews lost his cool and raised his tone to rail against the Coalition’s policy.

He said the state’s chief scientist, Dr Amanda Caples, was “totally independent” and she had made it apparent there were no known reserves where gas could be explored onshore using conventional methods.

Leaders questioned about Victoria’s budget and far-right candidates

By Sumeyya Ilanbey

Victoria’s premier and opposition leader have been quizzed about bringing the state together, while undecided voters wanted to know about the budget and far-right candidates.

Sky News host Kieran Gilbert asked Daniel Andrews and Matthew Guy how they would bring the state together after a horrid few years because of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Premier Daniel Andrews and Opposition Leader Matthew Guy at tonight’s debate.

Andrews responded by saying he was offering a positive and optimistic plan.

He revealed Reserve Bank governor Phillip Lowe told the national cabinet at the start of the COVID-19 pandemic that governments needed to borrow.

Premier Daniel Andrews and Opposition Leader Matthew Guy debate begins

By Sumeyya Ilanbey

Opposition Leader Matthew Guy looked calm as he kicked off tonight’s debate.

He spoke about his plans to fix the healthcare system, alleviate cost-of-living pressures and give Victorians confidence in the integrity of government.

The election debate between Victorian Premier Daniel Andrews and Opposition Leader Matthew Guy.skynews.com.au

He attempted to position the government as tired as he highlighted Labor’s dominance in this state.

Labor has been in power for 19 of the past 23 years, Guy said, and the problems in the state rested squarely on the shoulders of Labor governments.

Advertisement

Tricky mail-outs in Richmond

By Paul Sakkal

Labor sent Liberal Party-branded mail-outs to voters encouraging them to stop the Greens from capturing the seat of Richmond.

The Liberal Party made the contentious decision to direct Liberal voters to allocate their preferences to the Greens above Labor.

This means a higher proportion of Liberal votes will flow to the Greens when preferences are distributed, likely giving the minor party a better chance of winning the Labor-held electorate.

Liberal Party candidate for Richmond Lucas Moon hands out how-to- vote cards at an early voting centre.Scott McNaughton

Some voters in the inner-city seat, which takes in suburbs like Clifton Hill and Fitzroy, this week received pamphlets that use the same font, colours and logo as the Liberal Party.

Advertisement