Tom Rabe: Minns win
“Minns was able to better argue why his plan for more budget restraint was the right one. He pushed Perrottet onto the back foot several times, attacking him over the soaring debt he’s racked up.”
Matt Wade: Perrottet win
“In the end Perrottet managed to speak more about his government’s plan for the future. For that reason he edged Minns in a close contest.”
Jordan Baker: Minns win
“Perrottet seemed flustered during Wednesday’s debate; there was a sense of frustration that his narrative was not being understood. Minns was calm, almost casual. He drove the discussion and put Perrottet in a defensive position.”
Matt O’Sullivan: Perrottet win
“With so much at stake for both men, the debate was a civil affair just 10 days out from the state election. In the end, it was the Premier who had the slight edge in today’s contest.”
Harriet Alexander: Perrottet win
“Perrottet thumped his hand up and down like a metronome whenever he was given free rein, as though moderating his own momentum. He warned early of economic headwinds that would put jobs at risk, laying the groundwork for his own solutions, exuding urgency.”
Michael Koziol: Perrottet win
“Minns wants to damage Perrottet over debt and whether he’ll privatise assets to pay it down. But the Premier was convincing enough that infrastructure debt is good debt.”
Chris Minns: 3
Dominic Perrottet: 4
You can check out the full verdict here.