The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement

This was published 10 months ago

Doctor’s death cap poisoning warning played to jury after son, daughters of guests at fatal beef Wellington lunch testify: Trial day seven, as it happened

Marta Pascual Juanola and Erin Pearson
Updated ,first published

Jury dismissed for the day

By Marta Pascual Juanola and Erin Pearson

That concludes today’s evidence. Supreme Court judge Christopher Beale has dismissed the jury until tomorrow. We will have more for you in our next coverage. Here’s a wrap of what happened today:

  • A statement from church member Angela Child read to the court said she had seen Ian and Heather Wilkinson soon after the lunch and that the pair had raved about the beef Wellington prepared by Erin Patterson, describing it as delicious and beautiful.
  • Matthew Patterson, the son of Don and Gail Patterson and brother of Simon Patterson, told the court he had called Erin Patterson two days after the lunch to ask her about the source of the mushrooms. “She mentioned they were fresh mushrooms from Woolies and dried mushrooms from a Chinese grocer or supermarket,” he said.
  • A statement by a Health Department official said no cancer diagnosis had been registered for Erin Patterson. This conflicted with testimony given in court on Tuesday by Ian Wilkinson that Erin Patterson had told her guests at the lunch that she had cancer.
  • Dr Chris Webster told the jury that when Erin Patterson arrived at Leongatha Hospital reporting gastro symptoms, he told her she would require treatment. However, she discharged herself, against medical advice, and left the urgent care centre. “I was surprised,” he said. “I had just informed her that she had been potentially exposed to deadly death cap poison.”
  • Webster said he also urged Erin Patterson to get her children checked. “Erin was reluctant to inform the children. I said it was important. She was concerned that they were going to be frightened,” he told the court.
  • When asked about the source of the mushrooms, Webster said Erin Patterson gave him a short response. “Single word answer: ‘Woolworths’,” Webster told the jury. “I said there’s a concern from Dandenong Hospital of death cap mushroom poisoning.”

The trial will continue tomorrow.

Thanks for following our live coverage.

Photos from outside court

By

Award-winning photographer Jason South has taken these photos of Dr Veronica Foote, Dr Chris Webster and Ruth Dubois – the daughter of Ian and Heather Wilkinson – outside court, after each of them gave evidence today.

Dr Veronica Foote.Jason South
Dr Chris Webster.Jason South
Ruth Dubois, the daughter of Ian and Heather Wilkinson.Jason South

Remnants of beef Wellington meal delivered to hospital for examination, says doctor

By Marta Pascual Juanola

Dr Veronica Foote is detailing Erin Patterson’s second visit to the urgent care centre at Leongatha Hospital, about 10.30am on July 31, 2023.

Foote told the jury that Erin had reported having eaten the same meal as her lunch guests – Gail and Don Patterson and Heather and Ian Wilkinson – and said she had suffered diarrhoea since the night of July 29, 2023.

Don Patterson (left), Gail Patterson, Heather Wilkinson and Ian Wilkinson were poisoned by a mushroom meal.

Foote said Erin told her she had used mushrooms from “Safeway in Leongatha” as well as fungi from an Asian grocer that she had purchased in April of that year.

The jury heard that Erin’s abdomen was soft and her heart rate was slightly elevated.

Advertisement

CCTV footage shows Erin Patterson leaving hospital, after doctor said she urged her to stay

By Marta Pascual Juanola

The next witness is Dr Veronica Foote, a doctor at Leongatha Hospital.

Foote said the hospital’s director of nursing had told her that Erin Patterson had attended the urgent care centre about 8.05am on July 31, 2023.

Dr Veronica Foote.Jason South

The jury heard that when nurse Kylie Ashton had told Erin to go into a cubicle to be assessed, Erin wanted to leave the hospital.

Ashton asked Foote to speak to Erin as she stood near the hospital’s main entry point.

A question about the bin and the beef Wellington leftovers

By Marta Pascual Juanola

After a brief afternoon break, Dr Chris Webster provided further details about his phone call with police after Erin Patterson returned to Leongatha Hospital, when he asked officers to retrieve any leftovers from the beef Wellington lunch.

He told the jury he was on the phone to police and informing them that they no longer needed to look for Erin when it occurred to him to ask about the leftovers.

Webster said that he then thought it would be best to ask Erin if it was OK for the police to break into her home.

Asked by Supreme Court Justice Christopher Beale if Erin had said earlier in the conversation which bin the leftovers were in, Webster said she did not specify.

“When she said that they would find them in the bin I assumed that they would be in existence,” he said.

Webster has now concluded his evidence and been excused as a witness.

The single word answer Erin offered when grilled about source of mushrooms

By Marta Pascual Juanola

Under cross-examination by defence barrister Colin Mandy, SC, Dr Chris Webster said he was feeling concerned about the mushrooms in the beef Wellington meal when Erin Patterson presented to the Leongatha urgent care centre on July 31, 2023.

Webster said Heather Wilkinson had told him the day before that she and her husband Ian had eaten a beef Wellington.

Dr Chris Webster outside the court on Wednesday.Jason South

He had also spoken to Dr Beth Morgan at Dandenong Hospital, who had informed him there were concerns that Don and Gail Patterson could be suffering from death cap mushroom poisoning.

He said Erin gave a short response when he asked her about the source of the mushrooms.

“Single word answer: Woolworths,” Webster told the jury.

“I said there’s a concern from Dandenong Hospital of death cap mushroom poisoning.”

Advertisement

‘Scared or dead’: Doctor urged Erin Patterson to get kids checked

By Marta Pascual Juanola

Before leaving, Dr Chris Webster said he spoke to Erin Patterson one final time at Leongatha Hospital, while she was in the same room that Ian and Heather Wilkinson had been in before they were transferred to Dandenong Hospital.

Pastor Ian Wilkinson.Jason South

“I inquired as to the whereabouts of her children, and she informed me that they were at the school. I stressed the importance of getting the children to a medical facility for assessment. Erin was reluctant to inform the children. I said it was important. She was concerned that they were going to be frightened. I said they can be scared and alive, or dead,” Webster said.

Defence barrister Colin Mandy, SC, has now begun his cross-examination of Webster.

Triple 0 recording of doctor’s phone call played to jury

By Marta Pascual Juanola

The jury is now being played a recording of the 000 call that Dr Chris Webster made after Erin Patterson discharged herself against medical advice from Leongatha hospital on July 31, 2023.

In the phone call, Webster expressed concern that a patient had left the hospital after being potentially exposed to toxins from mushroom poisoning.

“I have the address of the patient,” Webster told the operator.

Asked for the patient’s name, Webster said: “The last name is Patterson. P-A-T-T-E-R-S-O-N. Erin, E-R-I-N,” Webster said.

‘I was surprised’: A doctor warned Patterson about potential poisoning – then she left

By Marta Pascual Juanola

Erin Patterson arrived at the urgent care centre in Leongatha and reported gastro symptoms. Dr Chris Webster recognised her as the person who had cooked the beef Wellington meal.

Almost as soon as she arrived, Webster said he started questioning her about mushrooms. There was a concern of death cap mushroom poisoning, he said.

“Where did you get the mushrooms?”

Erin Patterson is on trial for triple murder and attempted murder.The Age

Webster told the jury that he explained to Erin that she would require treatment. A while later, he was informed that Erin had discharged herself, against medical advice, and left the urgent care centre.

Advertisement

‘Grossly abnormal’ test results raised doctor’s fears about death cap mushroom poisoning

By Marta Pascual Juanola

Dr Chris Webster has returned to the witness box to continue his evidence after a break for lunch.

The jury heard that on the afternoon of July 30, 2023, a doctor contacted Webster by SMS informing him that Don and Gail Patterson had been sent to Melbourne due to high lactate levels.

Webster said that at the time, Ian and Heather Wilkinson’s lactate levels were “mildly elevated” but he did not consider sending them to Melbourne at that stage.

Dr Chris Webster, who initially treated Ian and Heather Wilkinson, resumed testimony on Wednesday afternoon.Jason South

“The heart rate, temperate and pressure, vital signs were stable. Intravenous fluid was being provided without complications and there were signs they were responding well to the initial treatment,” he said.

Advertisement