The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement

This was published 3 years ago

Chris Dawson sentencing LIVE updates: Lynette Dawson’s ex-husband jailed for minimum 18 years over murder

Michaela Whitbourn and Sarah McPhee
Updated ,first published
Pinned post from 12.49pm on Dec 2, 2022
Go to latest

A wrap of Chris Dawson’s sentence

By Michaela Whitbourn

Justice Ian Harrison has said Chris Dawson is likely to die in jail after he sentenced him to a minimum of 18 years in prison for the 1982 murder of his first wife, Lynette.

  • The sentence is backdated to August 30, when he was found guilty, and Dawson is first eligible for parole on August 30, 2040, at the age of 92.
  • Dawson’s full 24-year sentence would not expire until August 29, 2046, when he would be 98.
  • The NSW parliament passed new “no body, no parole” laws after Dawson was found guilty in August of murdering Lynette, whose body has never been found. The laws “make it impossible for offenders who willfully and deliberately refuse to disclose information about their victims’ remains to be granted parole”, Premier Dominic Perrottet said in September.
  • Harrison did not consider the extensive media attention surrounding Dawson’s criminal charges and trial as a mitigating factor. “As harsh as it may sound to say so, Mr Dawson is now the author of his own misfortune,” Harrison said.
  • Dawson’s sentence should reflect “the disapprobation with which his self-indulgent brutality must be viewed by Australian society”, the judge said.
  • Dawson has filed a notice of intention to appeal against his conviction.

    Read the full story here.

    Latest Posts

    ‘Our turn’ for freedom, Lynette’s family says

    By Michaela Whitbourn

    When she vanished from her northern beaches home in January 1982, Lynette Joy Simms left behind two adored daughters and a loving community of family and friends desperate for answers.

    Forty years later, her then-husband Chris Dawson is likely to die in prison, Justice Ian Harrison said today as he sentenced the former teacher and Newtown Jets rugby league player to a maximum of 24 years in prison for her murder. Dawson maintains his innocence and has lodged an intention to appeal against his conviction.

    Greg Simms (right) the brother of Lynette Dawson with his wife Merilyn Simms (left) leave the Law Courts building in Queens Square on Friday.Kate Geraghty

    “Chris Dawson has had 40 years of freedom. Now, it’s our turn,” Lynette’s brother Greg Simms said.

    Asked what freedom looked like, Simms paused.

    “We don’t know what we’re going to do. We’ve been pursuing this for 40 years.” It was time, he said, to “find out what normal really is like”.

    This is Michaela Whitbourn signing off on our live coverage. You can read more on the Dawson sentencing from my colleague Sarah McPhee here.

    Dawson author of his own misfortune, not media: Judge

    By Michaela Whitbourn

    As noted earlier today, Justice Ian Harrison considered the effect on Chris Dawson of significant publicity, both before he was charged in 2018 with the 1982 murder of his wife Lynette and after charges were laid and the matter proceeded to trial.

    When arriving at a sentence, judges may take into account extra-curial punishment, meaning punishment imposed on an offender other than by the court. This can include media coverage in some cases.

    Journalist Hedley Thomas released his podcast, The Teacher’s Pet, in 2018.Kate Geraghty

    Harrison said it was submitted on Dawson’s behalf “that in the course of this particular matter and over some considerable time, Mr Dawson has been exposed to what was described as ‘probably the most egregious publicity that one could consider in a context of the criminal law.’

    “I was referred in this respect to the findings of [Justice Elizabeth Fullerton and the then Chief Justice Tom Bathurst in pre-trial decisions].

    Family remembers Lynette as ‘happy, gentle, generous, loving’

    By Michaela Whitbourn

    Lynette’s brother Greg Simms said outside court today that “for our family, Lyn will always be remembered as a happy, gentle, generous, loving daughter, sister, mother, niece and friend”.

    It had been a “very long, painful and challenging journey”, Simms said after his former brother-in-law Chris Dawson was sentenced today to a maximum of 24 years in prison for murdering his then-wife Lynette, 33, in 1982.

    Lynette Dawson on ABC’s Chequerboard program in 1975.

    “At last we have justice for Lyn, and that was our main aim,” he said.

    Dawson was not charged over his wife’s murder until December 2018. He was found guilty of the crime by Justice Ian Harrison in August this year.

    “Chris Dawson discarded her; the Dawsons disregarded her; from today on, we would like her to be known and remembered as Lynette Joy Simms,” Greg Simms said.

    Advertisement

    Senior public defender will act in Dawson’s appeal

    By Michaela Whitbourn

    Speaking outside court before 1pm today, Chris Dawson’s lawyer Greg Walsh said he hadn’t yet had a chance to speak to his client after the sentence was handed down.

    Walsh said that for a number of reasons today would be his last day acting as Dawson’s lawyer. Dawson has filed a notice of intention to appeal against his conviction.

    Chris Dawson’s older brother Peter Dawson (left) and defence lawyer Greg Walsh (right) leave the Law Courts building in Queens Square on Friday.Kate Geraghty

    Senior public defender Belinda Rigg, SC, is expected to act in Dawson’s appeal.

    “It doesn’t matter what my view is,” Walsh said of the case. “I have an ethical obligation to act in accordance with his instructions and I’ve at all times done that.

    Dawson treated wife Lynette as ‘completely dispensable’: Judge

    By Michaela Whitbourn

    In comments later echoed outside of court by Lynette’s brother Greg Simms, Justice Ian Harrison said in his sentencing remarks today that Chris Dawson had treated his then-wife as “completely dispensable”.

    “Mr Dawson’s sentence should reflect the disapprobation with which his self-indulgent brutality must be viewed by Australian society,” he said, before sentencing Dawson to a maximum of 24 years in prison.

    Harrison said Dawson had murdered Lynette, then 33, in 1982 “for the selfish and cynical purpose of eliminating the inconvenient obstruction she presented to the creation of [a] ... new life with [babysitter and former student] JC”.

    “Tragically her death deprived her young daughters of their mother so that a significant part of the harm caused to others, and by inference to the community, as a consequence of her death, is the sad fact that Lynette Dawson was treated by her husband, the father of the very same girls, as completely dispensable,” Harrison said.

    Lynette’s brother Greg Simms said outside court that his sister should now be known by her maiden name.

    “Chris Dawson discarded her; the Dawsons disregarded her; from today on, we would like her to be known and remembered as Lynette Joy Simms,” he said.

    Police ‘hopeful’ about new information to find Lynette

    By Michaela Whitbourn

    The head of NSW’s homicide squad said a chapter had closed after Chris Dawson was sentenced today to a maximum of 24 years in prison for his wife Lynette’s murder in 1982 but police were hopeful new information may come to light about the location of her remains.

    “Whilst the chapter is closing, the book’s still open, the case is still open, because we still haven’t found Lyn,” NSW Police homicide squad commander Danny Doherty said outside court.

    Head of homicide Danny Doherty (right) addresses the media at the Law Courts building in Queens Square following the sentencing of Chris Dawson.Kate Geraghty

    “And I’m sure while the family, rightly so, want to get on with their lives, we will keep this case open in case we do get information, and I hope that we do get information to be able to provide some dignity to Lyn and let the family lay her to rest.

    “We were always hopeful that new evidence or information would come to hand. And we urge people to come forward if they have got information that’s going to be relevant and significant.”

    Advertisement

    Read the full judgment here

    By Michaela Whitbourn

    Justice Ian Harrison’s full remarks on Chris Dawson’s sentencing are available here. Here are some of his most significant comments and findings:

    • On the whereabouts of Lynette’s body: “The fact that Lynette Dawson’s body has never been located or recovered is an aggravating circumstance of the offence of murder. Concealment of the body is not limited in its significance to the absence of remorse,” Harrison said.
    Justice Ian Harrison in August.Nine
    • On the seriousness of the offence: “Murder is uncontroversially a serious crime. In my opinion, the murder of Lynette Dawson is an objectively very serious crime.”
    • On the pre-meditation: “Mr Dawson planned to kill his wife. Whatever means Mr Dawson employed to kill her, he intended that result. He did so in a domestic context and in her own home.”
    • On the suffering caused by Dawson:“Mr Dawson must be taken to have known and appreciated the injury, emotional harm and loss that his actions were likely to cause to Lynette Dawson’s daughters and her other relatives.”
    • On the importance of the sentence signalling the community’s disapproval: “Mr Dawson’s sentence should reflect the disapprobation with which his self-indulgent brutality must be viewed by Australian society.”
    Main photo: Chris Dawson before the announcement of the verdict in August. Inset: Dawson with Lynette on their wedding day in 1970.Kate Geraghty
    • On whether significant media attention was a mitigating factor on sentencing: “Simply put, Mr Dawson’s crime is a matter of intense public interest and the attention he has received is directly referable to that interest. It would be otherwise if media reports had significantly misrepresented his crime in a way that created a false perception of what he had done. Mr Dawson has now been convicted of the crime which attracted the publicity in question. In those circumstances, as harsh as it may sound to say so, Mr Dawson is now the author of his own misfortune.”
    • On the delay in Dawson being charged and prosecuted for the 1982 crime: “Mr Dawson has enjoyed 36 years in the community unimpeded by the taint of a conviction for killing his wife or by any punishment for doing so. In a practical sense, his denial of responsibility for that crime has benefited him in obvious ways ...I am unable to accept that Mr Dawson can legitimately embrace the alleged burdens of any delay without simultaneously being required to accept the benefits.”
    • On the length of sentence: “Mr Dawson is not old by contemporary standards but the reality is that he will not live to reach the end of his non-parole period or will alternatively, by reason of his deteriorating cognitive condition and physical capacity, become seriously disabled well before then even if he does. I am nevertheless required to impose a sentence that satisfies the community’s expectations of punishment, retribution and denunciation.”

    ‘Gavel of justice’ has fallen on Dawson: homicide squad boss

    By Michaela Whitbourn

    NSW Police homicide squad commander Danny Doherty also spoke outside court this afternoon and had this to say:

    Today, the gavel of justice came down on Chris Dawson and signalled the final chapters of this challenging and protracted criminal investigation and judicial process.

    I’d like to commend the spirit and thank the family for their unyielding spirit and their support and their search for the truth.

    I’d like to commend the investigators, both prior investigators and current investigators. This has been, since 2015, with the Unsolved Homicide Team under Strike Force Scriven.

    In early 2018, they submitted a compelling brief of evidence to the DPP which ultimately resulted in the arrest of Chris Dawson in late 2018.

    I’d also like to acknowledge the efforts of the DPP - their professional advocacy in this matter has been outstanding. So, thank you.

    Dawson showed ‘no emotion whatsoever’, Lynette’s brother says

    By Michaela Whitbourn

    Asked how the family felt about Chris Dawson’s appeal against his murder conviction, Lynette’s brother Greg Simms said: “He’s appealed everything else – he may as well go the full hog.

    “As far as we’re concerned, today – for us – is it. That’s it. Finito.”

    Loading

    He said he saw “no emotion whatsoever” in Dawson today.

    Simms said he believed Dawson would never reveal the location of his sister’s body.

    Advertisement

    Brother says Lynette should be known by her maiden name

    By Michaela Whitbourn

    Lynette’s brother Greg Simms, his wife Merilyn and their daughter Renee have appeared outside court after Chris Dawson was sentenced to a maximum of 24 years behind bars for Lynette’s murder.

    Greg Simms said his sister should be known by her maiden name.

    “Chris Dawson discarded her; the Dawsons disregarded her; from today on, we would like her to be known and remembered as Lynette Joy Simms,” he said.

    Greg Simms, the brother of Lynette Dawson, with his wife Merilyn Simms and daughter Renee Simms (left) arrive at the Supreme Court on Friday.Kate Geraghty

    “No sentence is long enough for taking someone’s life. We respect and thank Judge Harrison for his sentence and hope Chris Dawson lives a long life in order to serve that sentence.”

    Advertisement