The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement

This was published 4 years ago

As it happened: Proposed Victorian pandemic laws to be changed as state records 797 new COVID-19 cases, eight deaths; NSW Police return to Kendall home where William Tyrrell went missing

Broede Carmody and Michaela Whitbourn
Updated ,first published

The day in review

By Michaela Whitbourn

Good evening and thank you for reading our live coverage of the day’s events. If you are just joining us now, here’s what you need to know:

  • An Indigenous man wrongly identified by the Seven Network as the man taken into custody over the alleged abduction of four-year-old Cleo Smith has launched defamation proceedings against the media company in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. Terrance Flowers, a 27-year-old Nyamal man living in Karratha who uses his mother’s surname of Kelly on Facebook, was mistakenly identified by 7News on November 3 in broadcasts, an online article, a tweet and a Facebook post as the suspect in the case.

Ngaarda Media spoke with Terrance Flowers, the man wrongfully identified by 7News as the man in police custody over the abduction of Cleo Smith.Ngaarda Media
  • NSW Police have started their search for the remains of missing boy William Tyrrell, who disappeared in 2014 from the Mid North Coast town of Kendall. State Crime Command Director Detective Chief Superintendent Darren Bennett confirmed on Monday that police were looking for William’s remains and were acting “in response to evidence we have obtained in the course of the investigation” that was “not speculative in any way”. The Herald reported today that police are investigating whether the then three-year-old fell fatally from a balcony of the home where he was last seen. You can read more here.
NSW Police use a cadaver dog to search a site in Kendall for the remains of William Tyrrell.Wolter Peeters

Victorian Liberal MP rebuffs claims he stoked dangerous protests

By Marta Pascual Juanola

Victorian shadow treasurer David Davis has rebuffed claims he stoked dangerous demonstrations with his rhetoric against proposed pandemic laws being introduced to the upper house today.

Speaking to ABC Radio Melbourne this afternoon, Mr Davis said he did not regret addressing protesters during a rally on November 9 but condemned the use of gallows and death threats against Premier Daniel Andrews during several protests since Saturday.

Victoria’s shadow treasurer, David Davis.Penny Stephens

“That is not the Australian way, it’s not the Victorian way, demonstrations should be peaceful and respectful,” Mr Davies said.

“I did make it very clear that people had to focus on voting [in the next state election] in November next year. I did say to people that they should ring radio stations and write letters to the editor.

‘My direct family’: Labor Senator on nine new NT cases

By Sarah McPhee

Northern Territory Labor Senator Malarndirri McCarthy says the nine new COVID-19 cases announced today are her family members. The cluster in the Top End now stands at 11 cases.

The NT government says the cases are household contacts who live between two residences in Katherine. Their ages range from five to 71.

All have been transferred to the Howard Springs quarantine facility, except for a 65-year-old woman who has been admitted to Royal Darwin Hospital.

View post on X

In an update on social media this afternoon, Senator McCarthy said: “All of the new nine positive cases announced today are my direct family.

Advertisement

Man wrongly named as Cleo Smith abduction suspect launches defamation action against Seven

By Michaela Whitbourn

An Indigenous man wrongly identified by the Seven Network as the man taken into custody over the alleged abduction of four-year-old Cleo Smith has launched defamation proceedings against the media company in the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

Terrance Flowers, a 27-year-old Nyamal man living in Karratha who uses his mother’s surname of Kelly on Facebook, was mistakenly identified by 7News on November 3 in broadcasts, an online article, a tweet and a Facebook post as the suspect in the case.

Ngaarda Media spoke with Terrance Flowers, the man wrongfully identified by 7NEWS as the man in police custody over the abduction of Cleo Smith.Ngaarda Media

In fact, 36-year-old Carnarvon man Terence Darrell Kelly, whose first name is spelled differently, had been taken into custody by WA Police and was charged the following day with two offences including forcibly or fraudulently taking, enticing away or detaining a child under 16.

Seven was alerted to the error on the day of the publications and published an apology online that night. It subsequently apologised on air.

Biden, Xi begin superpower summit on friendly note

By Matthew Knott and Eryk Bagshaw

US President Joe Biden has told Chinese counterpart Xi Jinping that the leaders have a responsibility to the world not to let vigorous competition between the rival superpowers descend into war.

Describing Biden as an “old friend”, Xi said he wanted the US and China to improve their relationship by working closer together and by communicating more effectively.

President Joe Biden, left, speaks as he meets virtually with Chinese President Xi Jinping, on screen, from the Roosevelt Room of the White House in Washington on Monday, US time.Susan Walsh

Biden and Xi were speaking at the beginning of an expected three-hour-long teleconference summit that will be the pair’s longest and most substantive meeting since Biden’s inauguration in January.

Although the meeting began on a conciliatory note, both leaders were expected to address the most contentious areas of disagreement between them - including the future of Taiwan and China’s economic pressure against US allies such as Australia.

Speaking from the White House, Biden told Xi in his opening remarks: “As I’ve said before, it seems to me our responsibility as leaders of China and the United States is to ensure that the competition between our countries does not veer into conflict, whether intended or unintended.

Read the full story here.

‘A couple of thousand of my closest friends’: Victorian Opposition MPs rally behind Parliament House protesters

By Marta Pascual Juanola

Several Victorian Opposition MPs have rallied behind demonstrators calling for Premier Daniel Andrews to be sacked and for a bill changing the government’s powers during a pandemic to be scrapped.

Mr Andrews has said the proposed legislation, which passed the lower house last month, was modelled on laws in NSW and New Zealand.

Victorian Liberal MP Bernie Finn.Jason South

At the centre of the proposed laws is a move to give the premier of the day the power to make a pandemic “declaration”, rather than the Chief Health Officer. The premier would act on the advice of the CHO.

As Bianca Hall has written, this was designed to answer the criticism that an unelected official such as the CHO should not be responsible for declaring a pandemic given the consequences for freedom of movement, schools and businesses that Victorians have experienced during harsh lockdowns.

Advertisement

Perth family stranded in Simpson Desert set to be rescued by helicopter

By Heather McNeill

A Perth family-of-four stranded in the Simpson Desert for five days are expected to be rescued by helicopter on Tuesday afternoon.

Orios Zavros, his wife Lindsey and their children Zoe and Zane ran into trouble when their Mitsubishi Canter became bogged on Friday in remote South Australia during a cross-country holiday.

The Zavros family had been travelling across Australia in their van. Facebook

Stranded around 150 kilometres northwest of Oodnadatta, the family set off their emergency beacon on Friday, but were told it could take crews up to two weeks to reach them due to the recent flooding in the area.

The family were uninjured and had food and water supplies in their van.

Push to raise age of criminal responsibility to 12 too slow and soft: Commissioners

By Rachel Eddie

Australia’s children commissioners say a proposal for the states to consider raising the age of criminal responsibility to 12 “is not going hard or fast enough” and would fail hundreds of primary school-aged children who would still end up behind bars.

Instead, they want the age lifted from 10 to 14.

The Don Dale Youth Detention Centre in the NT was examined as part of a royal commission.Glenn Campbell

On Friday the states’ attorneys-general supported the development of a proposal to raise the age from 10, as revealed by The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald, without any timeline or hard commitment. The move comes three years after lawmakers began reviewing the issue.

Aboriginal organisations and legal groups have criticised it as a “nothing announcement”, saying it fell short of their push to raise the age to 14.

Australia and New Zealand’s 16 children’s commissioners and guardians on Tuesday added their criticism to the proposal, also urging every state and territory to urgently raise the age to 14 years.

Read the full story here.

‘Still plausible’ first rate rise won’t be before 2024: RBA

By Shane Wright

Reserve Bank governor Philip Lowe has conceded inflation could force the bank to lift official interest rates before its 2024 target while arguing it would still be highly unlikely.

Giving a speech on recent trends in inflation to a meeting of the Australian Business Economists, Dr Lowe on Tuesday sought to play down the risks of a breakout in price pressures that is now hitting some of the world’s largest economies.

RBA governor Philip Lowe says the most likely case for an interest rate rise remains 2024.Dominic Lorrimer

This week, Prime Minister Scott Morrison said the government was committed to “keeping downward pressure” on interest rates, which are at a record low of 0.1 per cent. The RBA is also creating $4 billion a week to support the financial system.

But with inflation at 6.2 per cent in the United States and global supply chains struggling to meet demand, financial markets are expecting the RBA to start lifting interest rates here by the middle of next year.

“It is still plausible that the first increase in the cash rate will not be before 2024,” Dr Lowe said.

Read the full story here.

Advertisement

Victoria’s proposed pandemic laws: what’s in them?

By Bianca Hall

Senior writer Bianca Hall has been poring over Victoria’s proposed pandemic laws in recent weeks and has written a guide to the changes (which are shifting as amendments are made).

Broadly, the laws will be the first pandemic-specific legislation in Australia and are designed to outline when and how the declaration of a pandemic can be made. Although sections of the laws have been welcomed, a raft of groups including the Victorian Bar, the Centre for Public Integrity and Liberty Victoria have raised concerns with what they say is the lack of strong oversight over what are extraordinary powers.

Right now, the Victorian Chief Health Officer is responsible for making a pandemic “declaration”. Under the new laws, it would be the premier’s role to do so on the advice of the CHO and the health minister.

This answers the criticism that an unelected official such as the CHO should not be responsible for declaring a pandemic given the consequences for freedom of movement, schools and businesses that Victorians have experienced during harsh lockdowns.

Advertisement