The Sydney Morning Herald logo
Advertisement

This was published 4 years ago

Australia news LIVE: Booster shot wait times accelerated in NSW, Victoria as COVID-19 cases grow across the nation; 2022 Australian Open continues in Melbourne

Broede Carmody and Michaela Whitbourn
Updated ,first published

The day in review

By Michaela Whitbourn and Broede Carmody

Good evening and thank you for reading our live coverage of the day’s events. If you are just joining us now, here’s what you need to know.

  • The Federal Court has published its reasons for rejecting world number one tennis player Novak Djokovic’s legal challenge on Sunday to the cancellation of his visa by the Morrison government. The court – Chief Justice James Allsop and Justices Anthony Besanko and David O’Callaghan – explained that its task was to decide whether the decision was lawful, and not to examine “the merits or wisdom of the decision”.
  • Immigration Minister Alex Hawke cancelled the unvaccinated tennis star’s visa this month on the basis his presence in Australia may pose a risk to “the health or good order of the Australian community” by stoking anti-vaccination sentiment. The Federal Court said that it was “not the fact of Mr Djokovic being a risk to the health, safety or good order of the Australian community” that was relevant, but “whether the Minister was satisfied that his presence is or may be or would or might be such a risk”. (The italics are in the judgment).
Immigration Minister Alex Hawke and Novak Djokovic.Alex Ellinghausen, AP
  • The court said Mr Hawke’s decision was not “irrational or illogical”, and “an iconic world tennis star may influence people of all ages, young or old, but perhaps especially the young and the impressionable, to emulate him”. “Another person in the position of the Minister may have not cancelled Mr Djokovic’s visa”, the court said, but the decision was lawful under the powers given to him by the Migration Act. It was “plainly open” to Mr Hawke to infer Djokovic was opposed to vaccination against COVID-19, the court said. The decision illustrates the breadth of the Immigration Minister’s powers to cancel a visa, and the relatively limited grounds on which the Federal Court can find such a decision is unlawful.
Prime Minister Scott Morrison on Thursday.Alex Ellinghausen

Tasmanian government to send RATs to parents under back-to-school plan

By Michaela Whitbourn

Tasmania says its schools will reopen on February 9 under a back-to-school plan that includes the provision of rapid antigen tests to parents.

The state government said in a media release today that “parents will receive a Back to School COVID Care Package, with detailed information and two Rapid Antigen Tests, per child, to have for use if your child becomes symptomatic and requires a test”.

Tasmanian Premier Peter Gutwein. Alex Ellinghausen

Schools will also be provided with “a further two tests for every student per week to take home to test if required due to being symptomatic”, the government said.

The government said masks would be worn indoors by secondary school students, and schools would be provided with masks. Children in early learning and child care settings will not wear masks, but primary school children will be given the option to wear a mask.

Northern Territory records 459 new cases of COVID-19

By Michaela Whitbourn

The Northern Territory has recorded 459 new cases of COVID-19, 364 of which were self-reported rapid antigen test results.

NT Chief Minister Michael Gunner said it took the number of active cases in the NT to “about” 3,970.

A COVID-19 testing site at Katherine in the Northern Territory.Krystle Wright

“There are currently 54 patients in hospital, with five patients requiring oxygen. One patient is in ICU,” he said.

Advertisement

Thailand to resume quarantine-free program for vaxxed arrivals

By

Thailand will resume a quarantine-free visa program for vaccinated visitors after its suspension last month helped the tourism-reliant nation curb a new wave of COVID-19 infections.

International travelers can start applying for visas under Thailand’s Test & Go entry program from February 1, Rachada Dhnadirek, a government spokeswoman, said on Twitter.

Boats, tourists and vendors pack into the Damnoen Saduak Floating Market near Bangkok, Thailand. iStock

The quarantine-free entry will be extended to applicants of all nationalities, and they will need to undergo two COVID tests; one upon arrival and another on the fifth day, Rachada said.

The decision to ease entry barriers for travelers is in line with the government’s call to treat COVID-19 as endemic this year and efforts to revive the tourism sector that employs millions of people.

Another Minister may have made a different decision, but Djokovic visa decision lawful

By Simone Fox Koob

As noted below, Immigration Minister Alex Hawke cancelled the visa of unvaccinated tennis star Novak Djokovic on the basis he might pose a risk of stoking anti-vaccination sentiment in the community.

The world number one’s lawyers argued in the Federal Court on Sunday that Mr Hawke had made a jurisdictional error because he was illogical, irrational or unreasonable in not considering whether cancelling Mr Djokovic’s visa may itself foster anti-vaccination sentiment in Australia.

The Federal Court – Chief Justice James Allsop and Justices Anthony Besanko and David O’Callaghan – disagreed and said the decision was lawful.

The court said the Minister had no obligation to consider what would happen if Djokovic was expelled from the country, only what would happen if he remained in Australia.

More information about Victoria’s new COVID-19 cases

By Cassandra Morgan

As we reported earlier today, another 15 people have died in Victoria with COVID-19.

They were aged in their 50s, 60s, 70s, 80s, and 90s, and their deaths bring the total number of deaths in the state since the pandemic began to 1751.

Of the 21,966 new COVID-19 cases the state reported on Thursday, 10,273 were recorded after people returned positive rapid antigen test results.

About 63 per cent of the people who self-reported their rapid antigen tests took the tests on Wednesday, while about 19 per cent took the tests on Tuesday. The remainder took their rapid antigen tests in the previous five days.

Advertisement

Djokovic visa decision not ‘irrational or illogical’: Federal Court

By Michaela Whitbourn

In its reasons for dismissing Novak Djokovic’s legal challenge to the cancellation of his visa, the Federal Court reiterates that the Migration Act says the Immigration Minister “may cancel a visa if he or she is satisfied that presence of its holder in Australia may be a risk to the health or good order of the Australian community”.

“The Minister [Alex Hawke] reached that state of satisfaction on grounds that cannot be said to be irrational or illogical or not based on relevant material,” the court said.

Immigration Minister Alex Hawke.Alex Ellinghausen

“Whether or not others would have formed that state of satisfaction and the state of satisfaction as to the public interest is a consideration not to the point.

“The relevant states of satisfaction were of matters which involved questions of fact, projections of the future and evaluations in the nature of opinion.

“That is the position in this case. Another person in the position of the Minister may have not cancelled Mr Djokovic’s visa. The Minister did. The complaints made in the proceeding do not found a conclusion that the satisfaction of the relevant factors and the exercise of discretion were reached and made unlawfully.”

On this basis, the court rejected the challenge and ordered Djokovic to pay the government’s legal costs.

An iconic tennis star ‘may influence people to emulate him’, court says

By Simone Fox Koob

As we’ve noted already, the Federal Court was asked to review Immigration Minister Alex Hawke’s decision to cancel Novak Djokovic’s visa on the basis that he may pose a risk to the “health, safety or good order of the Australian community”.

Lawyers for the federal government argued that the unvaccinated tennis star’s presence in Australia may stoke anti-vaccination sentiment.

Novak Djokovic left Australia on Sunday evening. AP

Djokovic’s legal team had argued on Sunday that Mr Hawke lacked any evidence to show the world number one’s presence may foster that sentiment.

The Federal Court had this to say about that line of reasoning:

Open to the Immigration Minister to infer Djokovic opposed vaccination: Federal Court

By Simone Fox Koob

It was “plainly open” to Immigration Minister Alex Hawke to infer Nokak Djokovic was opposed to vaccination against COVID-19, the Federal Court says in its reasons for rejecting a legal challenge by the tennis star to the cancellation of his visa.

The Serbian tennis star’s lawyers argued on Sunday that it was not open to Mr Hawke to make a finding about their client’s vaccination stance.

Novak Djokovic prepares to take his seat on a plane to Belgrade, in Dubai, United Arab Emirates, last Monday after being deported from Australia.AP

They said Mr Hawke had not sought Djokovic’s current views on vaccination, and had relied on “selective” comments from a BBC article titled “What has Novak Djokovic actually said about vaccines?”.

In written reasons for its decision, published on Thursday afternoon, the Federal Court said: “We reject the proposition that it was not open to the Minister to find or conclude that Mr Djokovic had a stance that was well-known on vaccination and that he was opposed to it.”

Advertisement

Immigration Minister provided ten pages of reasons for cancelling Djokovic visa

By Michaela Whitbourn

The Federal Court noted Immigration Minister Alex Hawke’s reasons for cancelling Novak Djokovic’s visa, “entitled ‘Statement of Reasons’, comprised ten pages and 71 paragraphs”.

In the reasons, Mr Hawke referred to medical advice from the Commonwealth Health Department that the unvaccinated tennis star “is unlikely to be infectious with SARS-COV-2 and as such is likely to constitute a LOW risk of transmitting SARS-CoV-2 to others”.

Immigration Minister Alex Hawke, left, and Novak Djokovic. Alex Ellinghausen, Getty

“Having regard to the specific additional control measures applicable to the Australian Open, ‘it is assessed that the risk of a transmission event related to the Australian Open is VERY LOW,’” the Department of Health advised the Minister.

Mr Hawke went on to say: “Although I make the assumptions above and accept that Mr Djokovic poses a negligible individual risk of transmitting COVID-19 to other persons, I nonetheless consider that his presence may be a risk to the health of the Australian community.”

He said he considered the world number one tennis player’s “presence in Australia may foster anti-vaccination sentiment leading to (a) other unvaccinated persons refusing to become vaccinated, (b) other unvaccinated persons being reinforced in their existing view not to become vaccinated, and/or (c) a reduction in the uptake of booster vaccines”.

The court said that “an important strand of reasoning was the Minister finding that Mr Djokovic was a high profile person with a position as a role model in the sporting and broader community”.

Advertisement